A2 Expression Neutral 5 min de lectura

That can't be right

Disbelief

En 15 segundos

  • Expresses surprise at incorrect information.
  • Signals disbelief and doubt.
  • Works in casual and semi-formal chats.
  • Use when facts don't match expectations.

Significado

Esta frase es tu recurso principal para expresar que una información simplemente no cuadra. Es como la campana de alarma interna de tu cerebro, que señala una discrepancia entre la realidad y lo que te están diciendo. Transmite una sensación de sorpresa genuina, a veces mezclada con un poco de escepticismo lúdico o incluso molestia leve, dependiendo de la situación. Piénsalo como una forma educada, pero firme, de decir: 'Espera un segundo, ¡aquí hay algo sospechoso!'

Ejemplos clave

3 de 12
1

Texting a friend about a bizarre event

You won the lottery AND got a promotion in the same week? `That can't be right!`

You won the lottery AND got a promotion in the same week? That can't be right!

2

At a café, checking the bill

Wait, $15 for a coffee? `That can't be right!`

Wait, $15 for a coffee? That can't be right!

3

Watching a documentary with surprising statistics

The documentary said over 80% of people believe that? `That can't be right.`

The documentary said over 80% of people believe that? That can't be right.

🌍

Contexto cultural

The phrase `That can't be right` likely emerged as a natural linguistic response to encountering information that contradicts established norms or perceived reality. Its existence highlights a fundamental human need to reconcile new information with existing knowledge and express cognitive dissonance when a mismatch occurs. It reflects a culture that values factual accuracy and logical consistency, providing a common way to question discrepancies without causing undue offense.

💡

Tone is Everything!

Saying `That can't be right` with a smile and a light tone makes it friendly. A sharp tone can sound accusatory, so watch your delivery!

🎯

Check Before You Claim

Use this when you're pretty sure something is wrong. If you later find out it *was* right, you might feel a bit silly!

En 15 segundos

  • Expresses surprise at incorrect information.
  • Signals disbelief and doubt.
  • Works in casual and semi-formal chats.
  • Use when facts don't match expectations.

What It Means

This phrase is your instant reaction when something sounds off. It's not just saying 'no,' it's expressing that the information you've received clashes with your understanding of reality. It signals surprise, doubt, and a strong feeling that there's an error somewhere. It’s like discovering a plot twist in a movie that makes no sense – you’d probably blurt this out.

How To Use It

You can use That can't be right in tons of everyday situations. Did your friend tell you they saw a celebrity at the local grocery store? That can't be right! Is your app showing your delivery is already at your door, but you're still in your pajamas? That can't be right! It's perfect for those moments when you need to express a quick, gut-level reaction to surprising or unbelievable news. It’s a verbal eyebrow-raise.

Formality & Register

This phrase is pretty flexible! It leans informal but can be used in semi-formal settings if delivered with a light tone. You wouldn't typically use it in a super serious, high-stakes business negotiation unless you knew the other person very well. For most everyday chats with friends, colleagues you know well, or even customer service interactions where something is clearly wrong, it fits perfectly. It’s more about the *way* you say it than the phrase itself.

Real-Life Examples

Imagine you're checking your online bank statement and see a charge for $500 for a pizza. You'd likely exclaim, That can't be right! Or maybe your friend boasts about finishing a marathon without any training. You might chuckle and say, Seriously? That can't be right! Even if a streaming service suggests a movie you've watched 10 times as 'new,' you might think, That can't be right. It works for everything from silly anecdotes to potentially serious errors.

When To Use It

Use That can't be right when you encounter information that seems factually incorrect, highly improbable, or completely unexpected. It's great for questioning unexpected results, surprising statistics, or unbelievable stories. Think of it as a polite way to express skepticism without outright accusing someone of lying. It's your verbal equivalent of a double-take. It's also useful when you've made a mistake yourself, like realizing you've sent an email to the wrong person – 'Oh no, That can't be right!'

When NOT To Use It

Avoid this phrase in highly formal situations, like presenting findings to a board of directors or during a solemn ceremony. It can sound dismissive or disrespectful. Also, if someone is sharing deeply personal or sensitive news (like a loss), this phrase would be incredibly inappropriate. It's meant for factual discrepancies or surprising but generally lighthearted situations, not for invalidating someone's feelings or experiences. Don't use it if you're 99.9% sure something IS right, even if it seems odd at first glance.

Common Mistakes

A common slip-up is using it too aggressively. If you say That can't be right! with a harsh tone, it can sound confrontational. People might think you're accusing them of being wrong or dishonest. Another mistake is using it when the information is actually correct but just surprising. You might later find out your friend *did* win the lottery – then saying That can't be right looks a bit silly. Always consider the certainty of the information before blurting it out.

Common Variations

In British English, you might hear That can't be right, can it? adding a tag question for a softer feel. Younger generations might text No way! or Fr? (for real?) instead, which conveys similar disbelief but is much more casual. In some contexts, people might say You're pulling my leg! or You've got to be kidding me! which are more colorful ways to express the same idea. The core meaning of disbelief remains, but the flavor changes.

Real Conversations

Scenario 1: Friend A tells Friend B about a crazy price.

Friend A: I just bought this designer bag for only $20!

Friend B: No way! That can't be right. Was it on sale?

Scenario 2: Colleague discussing a project deadline.

Colleague 1: The report is due tomorrow morning.

Colleague 2: Tomorrow? But we just got the data today!

Colleague 1: Yep.

Colleague 2: That can't be right. I thought we had another week.

Quick FAQ

Q. Is this phrase polite?

A. Generally, yes, if said with a friendly tone. It expresses surprise rather than accusation. However, tone is key!

Q. Can I use it in a text message?

A. Absolutely! It's very common in texts and social media comments. It's a quick way to react.

Q. What if I'm wrong?

A. If you find out you were mistaken, just say something like, 'Oh, my mistake! I guess I was wrong about that.' No big deal!

Q. Does it work for personal opinions?

A. It's best for factual statements or unbelievable events, not really for opinions. You wouldn't say That can't be right about someone's favorite color.

Notas de uso

This phrase is versatile, fitting well in casual chats with friends and even semi-formal situations when questioning factual errors politely. Avoid it in highly formal settings or when discussing sensitive personal matters, as it can sound dismissive. The key is delivering it with a tone of genuine surprise rather than accusation.

💡

Tone is Everything!

Saying `That can't be right` with a smile and a light tone makes it friendly. A sharp tone can sound accusatory, so watch your delivery!

🎯

Check Before You Claim

Use this when you're pretty sure something is wrong. If you later find out it *was* right, you might feel a bit silly!

⚠️

Avoid Formal Blunders

Resist the urge to use `That can't be right` in very formal meetings or serious discussions. Opt for phrases like 'Could you clarify that?' or 'I have some concerns about these figures.'

💬

The British Tag

In the UK, you might hear `That can't be right, can it?` The added 'can it?' softens the disbelief, making it sound more like a gentle query than a firm statement.

Ejemplos

12
#1 Texting a friend about a bizarre event

You won the lottery AND got a promotion in the same week? `That can't be right!`

You won the lottery AND got a promotion in the same week? That can't be right!

Expresses strong disbelief at a friend's unbelievable good fortune.

#2 At a café, checking the bill

Wait, $15 for a coffee? `That can't be right!`

Wait, $15 for a coffee? That can't be right!

Highlights surprise and doubt about an unexpectedly high price.

#3 Watching a documentary with surprising statistics

The documentary said over 80% of people believe that? `That can't be right.`

The documentary said over 80% of people believe that? That can't be right.

Expresses skepticism about a statistic that seems too high or unlikely.

#4 Instagram caption on a funny mistake

My GPS tried to send me into a lake today. `That can't be right.` 😂 #fail

My GPS tried to send me into a lake today. That can't be right. 😂 #fail

Humorous disbelief at a technological error.

#5 Responding to a friend's unbelievable story

You met your favorite actor at the bus stop? `That can't be right!`

You met your favorite actor at the bus stop? That can't be right!

Expresses playful skepticism about an improbable encounter.

#6 Job interview - questioning a stated requirement

You mentioned this role requires 10 years of experience for an entry-level position? `That can't be right.`

You mentioned this role requires 10 years of experience for an entry-level position? That can't be right.

Politely points out a perceived contradiction or error in job requirements.

#7 Email to a colleague about a project error

I just double-checked the figures, and the total comes to $5,000, not $50,000. `That can't be right.` Please verify.

I just double-checked the figures, and the total comes to $5,000, not $50,000. That can't be right. Please verify.

Expresses doubt about a significant numerical error in a professional context.

Mistake: Texting a friend Error común

✗ I heard you're moving to Antarctica next week. That can't be right, can you?

I heard you're moving to Antarctica next week. That can't be right, can you?

The tag question `can you?` makes it sound like you're asking for confirmation of the unbelievable news, not expressing disbelief.

Mistake: Casual conversation Error común

✗ My dog is fluent in French. That can't be right, is it?

My dog is fluent in French. That can't be right, is it?

Adding `is it?` makes it sound like you're unsure and seeking confirmation, weakening the expression of disbelief.

#10 Reacting to a plot twist in a movie

He was the villain all along? `That can't be right!`

He was the villain all along? That can't be right!

Expresses shock and disbelief at a surprising plot development.

#11 Reacting to a friend's unbelievable claim

You finished the entire season in one day? `That can't be right!`

You finished the entire season in one day? That can't be right!

Expresses disbelief at the speed someone consumed a TV show.

#12 Checking an order confirmation

I ordered one pizza, but the confirmation says three. `That can't be right.`

I ordered one pizza, but the confirmation says three. That can't be right.

Expresses doubt about an incorrect order detail.

Ponte a prueba

Fill in the blank with the correct phrase.

✓ ¡Correcto! ✗ No del todo. Respuesta correcta: That can't be right

`That can't be right` expresses disbelief about the flight cancellation and rebooking.

Choose the sentence that uses the phrase correctly.

Which sentence correctly expresses disbelief?

✓ ¡Correcto! ✗ No del todo. Respuesta correcta: The concert tickets were only $5! That can't be right.

The first option correctly uses the phrase to express surprise at a very low price.

Find and fix the error in the sentence.

✓ ¡Correcto! ✗ No del todo. Respuesta correcta:

Adding 'is it?' makes the phrase sound like a question seeking confirmation, rather than a statement of disbelief. A simple exclamation mark is more appropriate here.

Fill in the blank with the correct phrase.

✓ ¡Correcto! ✗ No del todo. Respuesta correcta: That can't be right

The phrase expresses doubt about the car's capacity, fitting the context of disbelief.

Translate this sentence into English.

✓ ¡Correcto! ✗ No del todo. Respuesta correcta:

The French sentence expresses strong disbelief about a price, perfectly matching the English phrase `That can't be right.`

Choose the sentence that uses the phrase correctly.

Which sentence uses 'That can't be right' appropriately?

✓ ¡Correcto! ✗ No del todo. Respuesta correcta: The weather forecast says snow in July. That can't be right.

The first option expresses disbelief about an unlikely weather event (snow in July).

Find and fix the error in the sentence.

✓ ¡Correcto! ✗ No del todo. Respuesta correcta:

The tag question 'can it?' softens the disbelief into uncertainty. For strong disbelief, an exclamation mark is better.

Fill in the blank with the correct phrase.

✓ ¡Correcto! ✗ No del todo. Respuesta correcta: That can't be right

The phrase expresses disbelief at an unexpectedly low (zero) order total.

Put the words in the correct order to form a sentence.

✓ ¡Correcto! ✗ No del todo. Respuesta correcta:

This is the standard word order for the expression of disbelief.

Translate this sentence into English.

✓ ¡Correcto! ✗ No del todo. Respuesta correcta:

The German sentence expresses strong disbelief and impossibility, which is captured by `I don't believe you, that can't be right!`

Choose the sentence that uses the phrase correctly in a professional context.

Which sentence is appropriate for a professional setting?

✓ ¡Correcto! ✗ No del todo. Respuesta correcta: The invoice total is $10,000? That can't be right.

The first option politely questions a surprisingly high invoice amount, suitable for a professional context.

Find and fix the error in the sentence.

✓ ¡Correcto! ✗ No del todo. Respuesta correcta:

While the sentiment is understandable, adding 'what a disaster' after the phrase dilutes its direct expression of disbelief. A simple exclamation mark is cleaner.

🎉 Puntuación: /12

Ayudas visuales

Formality Spectrum for 'That can't be right'

Very Informal

Used freely with close friends, often with exaggerated tone.

You saw a ghost? That can't be right!

Informal

Common in everyday conversations with friends, family, and familiar colleagues.

Wait, the store is closed already? That can't be right.

Neutral/Semi-Formal

Can be used cautiously in professional settings when questioning factual errors politely.

The report states the project is complete, but we're still missing key data. That can't be right.

Very Formal

Generally avoided in highly formal or sensitive situations.

Formal business meeting: 'The figures presented appear inconsistent.' (Instead of 'That can't be right!')

Situations Where 'That Can't Be Right' Fits

Expressing Disbelief
🧾

Checking a bill/receipt

£50 for a haircut? That can't be right!

📰

Hearing surprising news

You got the job? That can't be right!

📊

Questioning a statistic

Only 5% of people do that? That can't be right.

Reacting to a mistake (own or others')

I sent the email to the wrong person! That can't be right!

🛒

Online shopping error

The delivery estimate is 6 months? That can't be right.

🗺️

Following improbable instructions

Turn left into the lake? That can't be right.

Comparing Disbelief Expressions

That can't be right
Core Meaning Expresses doubt about factual accuracy or possibility.
Vibe Surprise mixed with skepticism; polite questioning.
Usage Works for facts, numbers, claims.
You've got to be kidding me!
Core Meaning Strong disbelief, often used for surprising or absurd situations.
Vibe More emphasis on the absurdity; can be playful or exasperated.
Usage Often for stories, events, or outcomes.
Seriously?
Core Meaning A direct question seeking confirmation or expressing doubt.
Vibe Can range from playful skepticism to genuine questioning.
Usage Versatile, works for statements, questions, or actions.

Usage Scenarios for 'That Can't Be Right'

💰

Financial Shockers 💸

  • Incorrect bill amount
  • Unexpectedly high charge
  • Wrong price tag
📣

Surprising News 📣

  • Unlikely event
  • Improbable achievement
  • Shocking announcement
⚙️

Tech & Data Glitches 💻

  • App error message
  • Wrong statistic
  • GPS mistake
🤦

Personal Mistakes 🤦

  • Sent email to wrong person
  • Forgot an important task
  • Made a silly error

Banco de ejercicios

12 ejercicios
Fill in the blank with the correct phrase. Fill Blank beginner

My flight got cancelled and rebooked for next week? ___!

✓ ¡Correcto! ✗ No del todo. Respuesta correcta: That can't be right

`That can't be right` expresses disbelief about the flight cancellation and rebooking.

Choose the sentence that uses the phrase correctly. Choose beginner

Which sentence correctly expresses disbelief?

✓ ¡Correcto! ✗ No del todo. Respuesta correcta: The concert tickets were only $5! That can't be right.

The first option correctly uses the phrase to express surprise at a very low price.

Find and fix the error in the sentence. Error Fix intermediate

Encuentra y corrige el error:

I thought the meeting was at 3 PM, but it's at 3 AM? That can't be right, is it?

✓ ¡Correcto! ✗ No del todo. Respuesta correcta: I thought the meeting was at 3 PM, but it's at 3 AM? That can't be right!

Adding 'is it?' makes the phrase sound like a question seeking confirmation, rather than a statement of disbelief. A simple exclamation mark is more appropriate here.

Fill in the blank with the correct phrase. Fill Blank intermediate

You're telling me this tiny car fits eight people? ___!

✓ ¡Correcto! ✗ No del todo. Respuesta correcta: That can't be right

The phrase expresses doubt about the car's capacity, fitting the context of disbelief.

Translate this sentence into English. Traducir intermediate

Ce prix pour cette voiture? Ça ne peut pas être vrai!

Pistas: The French 'Ça ne peut pas être vrai' directly translates to 'It cannot be true'., Consider the context of disbelief.

✓ ¡Correcto! ✗ No del todo. Respuesta correcta: This price for this car? That can't be right!

The French sentence expresses strong disbelief about a price, perfectly matching the English phrase `That can't be right.`

Choose the sentence that uses the phrase correctly. Choose intermediate

Which sentence uses 'That can't be right' appropriately?

✓ ¡Correcto! ✗ No del todo. Respuesta correcta: The weather forecast says snow in July. That can't be right.

The first option expresses disbelief about an unlikely weather event (snow in July).

Find and fix the error in the sentence. Error Fix advanced

Encuentra y corrige el error:

He claims he finished the marathon in under two hours. That can't be right, can it?

✓ ¡Correcto! ✗ No del todo. Respuesta correcta: He claims he finished the marathon in under two hours. That can't be right!

The tag question 'can it?' softens the disbelief into uncertainty. For strong disbelief, an exclamation mark is better.

Fill in the blank with the correct phrase. Fill Blank advanced

You're saying my order total is $0.00? ___!

✓ ¡Correcto! ✗ No del todo. Respuesta correcta: That can't be right

The phrase expresses disbelief at an unexpectedly low (zero) order total.

Put the words in the correct order to form a sentence. Reorder advanced

Ordena las palabras en el orden correcto:

Haz clic en las palabras de arriba para construir la oracion

✓ ¡Correcto! ✗ No del todo. Respuesta correcta: That can't be right

This is the standard word order for the expression of disbelief.

Translate this sentence into English. Traducir advanced

Ich glaube dir nicht, das ist doch unmöglich!

Pistas: 'Ich glaube dir nicht' means 'I don't believe you'., 'das ist doch unmöglich' means 'that is impossible'.

✓ ¡Correcto! ✗ No del todo. Respuesta correcta: I don't believe you, that can't be right!

The German sentence expresses strong disbelief and impossibility, which is captured by `I don't believe you, that can't be right!`

Choose the sentence that uses the phrase correctly in a professional context. Choose advanced

Which sentence is appropriate for a professional setting?

✓ ¡Correcto! ✗ No del todo. Respuesta correcta: The invoice total is $10,000? That can't be right.

The first option politely questions a surprisingly high invoice amount, suitable for a professional context.

Find and fix the error in the sentence. Error Fix advanced

Encuentra y corrige el error:

My flight got delayed by 10 hours. That can't be right, what a disaster!

✓ ¡Correcto! ✗ No del todo. Respuesta correcta: My flight got delayed by 10 hours. That can't be right!

While the sentiment is understandable, adding 'what a disaster' after the phrase dilutes its direct expression of disbelief. A simple exclamation mark is cleaner.

🎉 Puntuación: /12

Preguntas frecuentes

18 preguntas

It means you strongly suspect that something you've heard or seen is incorrect or impossible. It's a way to express surprise and doubt when information doesn't seem to match reality or your expectations.

Use it when you encounter information that seems factually wrong, highly improbable, or completely unexpected. It's perfect for questioning surprising statistics, unbelievable stories, or obvious errors in orders or bills.

No, it's generally considered informal to neutral. While you might use it with colleagues you know well to point out a mistake, it's usually too casual for very formal business presentations or official documents.

Absolutely! It's very common in texting and social media. It's a quick and effective way to react to something surprising or unbelievable you see online or hear from a friend.

The tone is typically one of surprise and skepticism. It can be playful, genuinely questioning, or slightly exasperated, depending on your vocal inflection and the context of the situation.

Yes, there are! You could say 'No way!', 'You're kidding me!', 'Seriously?', 'Get out of here!', or 'That's unbelievable!' The best choice depends on how informal you want to be and the specific situation.

'No way!' is usually more informal and expresses a stronger, more immediate sense of shock or disbelief. 'That can't be right' is slightly more measured and often implies a specific factual error that needs checking.

A common variation in British English is adding a tag question, like 'That can't be right, can it?'. This makes the expression sound a bit softer and more conversational, inviting confirmation.

If you use 'That can't be right' and later find out the information was actually correct, it's easy to backtrack. You can simply say, 'Oh, my mistake! I guess I was wrong about that,' or 'Okay, I stand corrected.'

Yes, it can definitely be used sarcastically. If someone says something obviously untrue or ridiculous, you might say 'Oh yeah, That can't be right...' with a knowing tone to imply you don't believe them at all.

It depends heavily on your relationship and the context. In most cases, it's safer to use more formal phrasing like, 'Could you help me understand this figure?' or 'I seem to have a different number here.' Using 'That can't be right' directly might sound dismissive.

A frequent mistake is adding tag questions like 'is it?' or 'can it?' at the end, such as 'That can't be right, is it?'. This turns the statement of disbelief into a hesitant question, weakening its impact.

Google Translate might offer literal translations or common equivalents like 'That cannot be true' or 'It can't be right'. While often accurate, it might miss the subtle nuances of surprise or skepticism conveyed by the English phrase in specific contexts.

It's generally best used for factual statements, data, or events that seem impossible or incorrect. You wouldn't typically use it to disagree with someone's opinion, like 'I think blue is the best color.' Saying 'That can't be right' about an opinion would sound dismissive.

The phrase likely evolved naturally from combining basic English words to express a logical contradiction. It's a direct statement of impossibility, reflecting a universal human reaction to encountering information that clashes with perceived reality.

'That's wrong' is a direct statement of incorrectness, often sounding more assertive or accusatory. 'That can't be right' emphasizes the speaker's surprise and disbelief, suggesting the information is so unlikely it *must* be an error.

Yes, if the prediction seems highly improbable. For example, if someone predicts 'It will snow in August here,' you could respond, 'That can't be right!' It expresses doubt about the likelihood of the future event.

In online comments, 'That can't be right' often signals skepticism towards a claim, a statistic, or a piece of news shared. It's a way to question the validity of the information without necessarily being aggressive.

Frases relacionadas

😊

No way!

informal version

Expresses strong disbelief or surprise.

This is a more informal and often more emphatic way to express disbelief, suitable for casual conversations.

😊

You've got to be kidding me!

informal version

Expresses disbelief, often at something absurd or surprising.

This phrase is more colorful and informal, emphasizing the absurdity of the situation being discussed.

👔

That's incorrect.

formal version

States directly that something is wrong.

This is a more direct and formal way to state that information is wrong, suitable for professional contexts where 'That can't be right' might sound too casual.

🔗

Are you sure about that?

related topic

Politely questions the accuracy of a statement.

This phrase is used to gently inquire about the certainty of information, often preceding or following an expression of disbelief.

🔄

That doesn't sound right.

synonym

Expresses doubt about the plausibility of something.

This phrase is very similar in meaning and usage, conveying skepticism about the correctness or likelihood of a statement.

😊

Get out of here!

informal version

Expresses strong disbelief or surprise, often playfully.

This is a highly informal and often playful exclamation used to show you find something hard to believe.

¿Te ha servido?
¡No hay comentarios todavía. Sé el primero en compartir tus ideas!