Bedeutung
someone without a distinct character
Kultureller Hintergrund
The distinction between 'fish' and 'meat' was central to the Russian calendar for centuries due to strict fasting rules. This binary created a mental map where everything had its place. In a society that valued collective action, being 'gray' or 'neutral' was often seen as a lack of revolutionary spirit. The phrase was used to shame those who didn't take a side. Today, the phrase is often used to describe a lack of 'soft skills' or leadership potential. In a competitive market, being 'bland' is a professional liability. Classic Russian authors like Turgenev and Chekhov often used this phrase to describe 'superfluous men'—intelligent but passive characters who couldn't find their place in society.
The No-Comma Rule
Impress native speakers by NOT putting a comma. Most Russians forget this rule, so you'll look like a grammar pro!
Don't use it to their face
It's a fairly strong insult to someone's personality. Use it when talking *about* someone, not *to* them.
Bedeutung
someone without a distinct character
The No-Comma Rule
Impress native speakers by NOT putting a comma. Most Russians forget this rule, so you'll look like a grammar pro!
Don't use it to their face
It's a fairly strong insult to someone's personality. Use it when talking *about* someone, not *to* them.
Use with 'какой-то'
Adding 'какой-то' (some kind of) before the idiom makes it sound much more natural and native: 'Он какой-то ни рыба ни мясо'.
Teste dich selbst
Fill in the missing words of the idiom (remember: no commas!).
Он никогда не спорит и всегда соглашается с большинством. Он какой-то ни _______ ни _______.
The standard idiom is 'ни рыба ни мясо'.
Which sentence uses the idiom correctly regarding punctuation?
Выберите правильный вариант:
Fixed idioms in Russian do not take a comma between repeating conjunctions.
Match the situation to the most appropriate use of the idiom.
В какой ситуации лучше всего сказать 'ни рыба ни мясо'?
The idiom describes indecisive or bland people.
🎉 Ergebnis: /3
Visuelle Lernhilfen
Aufgabensammlung
3 AufgabenОн никогда не спорит и всегда соглашается с большинством. Он какой-то ни _______ ни _______.
The standard idiom is 'ни рыба ни мясо'.
Выберите правильный вариант:
Fixed idioms in Russian do not take a comma between repeating conjunctions.
В какой ситуации лучше всего сказать 'ни рыба ни мясо'?
The idiom describes indecisive or bland people.
🎉 Ergebnis: /3
Häufig gestellte Fragen
4 FragenYes, about 95% of the time. It implies the person is boring, weak, or useless. Occasionally it can be a neutral description of a mediocre object, but for people, it's negative.
Only as a joke. If you say 'This soup is ни рыба ни мясо,' people will think you are being clever, but usually, it's for personalities.
Russian grammar rules state that fixed idiomatic expressions (фразеологизмы) consisting of two opposing or related parts with 'ни... ни' do not require a comma.
It's okay for internal discussions about candidates or competitors, but too informal for a presentation or a client meeting.
Verwandte Redewendungen
ни то ни сё
synonymneither this nor that
ни пава ни ворона
similarneither a peacock nor a crow
ни богу свечка ни чёрту кочерга
synonymneither a candle for God nor a poker for the Devil
средней руки
similarof average quality
