A1 Past Tense 8 min read Medium

French Past Participle Agreement with Infinitives (entendu chanter)

Only agree the past participle if the preceding direct object is the one doing the following infinitive action.

Grammar Rule in 30 Seconds

When a past participle is followed by an infinitive, it only agrees if the preceding direct object performs the action.

  • If the direct object does the action, the participle agrees: 'La chanson que j'ai entendue chanter.'
  • If the direct object receives the action, the participle stays neutral: 'La chanson que j'ai entendu chanter.'
  • The participle 'fait' followed by an infinitive never agrees: 'Les maisons que j'ai fait construire.'
Direct Object + (avoir) + Participle + Infinitive = Agreement check 🔍

Overview

At the heart of French grammar lies the concept of agreement, a system that ensures different parts of a sentence correctly reflect each other in gender and number. One of the most nuanced agreement rules governs the past participle when used with the auxiliary avoir. While you may already know the basic rule—that the participle agrees with a preceding direct object—a specific and more complex situation arises when this past participle is followed by an infinitive verb.

This structure is especially common with verbs of perception, like voir (to see) and entendre (to hear).

This isn't just a random rule; it's based on a linguistic logic that asks: who is performing the action of the infinitive? Is the direct object the one doing the action, or is the action happening to it? Correctly answering this question is the key to mastering this pattern. For a beginner at the A1 level, this may seem advanced, but understanding it early will prevent common errors and build a strong foundation for more complex sentences.

It distinguishes between les musiciens que j'ai entendus jouer (the musicians I heard play) and la musique que j'ai entendu jouer (the music I heard played).

This article will deconstruct this rule from the ground up. We'll start with the fundamental concepts of direct objects and past participles before moving to the core logical test. We will explore which verbs this applies to, the major exceptions you must know (like faire), and how this grammar appears in real-world French, from formal writing to casual text messages.

By the end, you'll have a clear framework for analyzing these sentences and applying the agreement correctly every time.

Conjugation Table

Verb (Infinitive) Masculine Singular (Default) Feminine Singular (+e) Masculine Plural (+s) Feminine Plural (+es)
:--- :--- :--- :--- :---
voir (to see) vu vue vus vues
entendre (to hear) entendu entendue entendus entendues
regarder (to watch) regardé regardée regardés regardées
écouter (to listen to) écouté écoutée écoutés écoutées
laisser (to let/allow) laissé laissée laissés laissées

How This Grammar Works

To understand this specific rule, you first need to be comfortable with the standard past participle agreement with avoir. Let's quickly review it before adding the infinitive.
The rule is: when a verb is conjugated in a compound tense with avoir (like the passé composé), the past participle agrees in gender and number with the direct object (in French, the COD - complément d'objet direct), but only if the direct object comes before the verb.
  • No preceding object: J'ai acheté des pommes. (des pommes is after the verb, so no agreement on acheté).
  • Preceding object: Les pommes que j'ai achetées... (The relative pronoun que represents les pommes, placing the object before the verb, so acheté becomes achetées).
Now, let's introduce an infinitive. When a past participle is followed by an infinitive, the agreement rule gets a new layer of logic. The agreement now depends on whether the preceding direct object is the logical subject of that infinitive.
In simpler terms, you must ask: Is the direct object the one performing the action of the infinitive?
Scenario 1: The direct object DOES the action -> Agreement
If the direct object is the one performing the action of the infinitive, the past participle agrees with it.
  • Example: J'ai vu les filles. + Les filles courent. -> Les filles que j'ai vues courir.
  • Analysis: The direct object is les filles (feminine, plural). Who is doing the action of courir (to run)? The girls. Because the girls are the logical subject of courir, the past participle vu must agree with les filles, becoming vues.
Scenario 2: The direct object DOES NOT do the action -> No Agreement
If the direct object is the recipient of the infinitive's action (the action is done to it), the past participle remains invariant (unchanged, in its masculine singular form).
  • Example: J'ai entendu une chanson. + Quelqu'un chante la chanson. -> La chanson que j'ai entendu chanter.
  • Analysis: The direct object is la chanson (feminine, singular). Who is doing the action of chanter (to sing)? Not the song itself. Someone else sings the song. Because la chanson is not the logical subject of chanter, the past participle entendu does not agree and stays in its default entendu form.
This principle is the entire foundation of the rule. It forces you to think about the meaning of the sentence, not just the placement of the words. The past participle agrees when it describes an object that is also an actor.

Formation Pattern

1
To apply this rule correctly and consistently, follow this systematic, two-step process. Don't try to guess; analyze the sentence structure deliberately.
2
Step 1: Identify the Key Grammatical Components
3
First, locate the three essential parts of the structure in your sentence:
4
The Preceding Direct Object (COD): The noun or pronoun that comes before the avoir verb group. It's often introduced by que.
5
The Past Participle: The verb form immediately following the avoir auxiliary (e.g., vu, entendu, laissé).
6
The Infinitive: The verb in its base form that follows the past participle (e.g., chanter, courir, construire).
7
Example: Les enfants que j'ai vus jouer dans le parc...
8
COD: Les enfants (represented by que)
9
Past Participle: vus
10
Infinitive: jouer
11
Step 2: Perform the Logical Subject Test
12
Once you've identified the components, ask the single most important question:
13
"Is the preceding direct object the one performing the action of the infinitive?"
14
Your answer will be either YES or NO, which dictates the agreement:
15
| Logical Subject Test Result | Rule to Apply | Example & Explanation |
16
| :--- | :--- | :--- |
17
| YES | The past participle agrees in gender and number with the preceding direct object. | Les actrices que j'ai vues jouer. (Did the actresses jouer? Yes. -> vues agrees with actrices.) |
18
| NO | The past participle is invariant (remains in its default masculine singular form). | La pièce de théâtre que j'ai vu jouer. (Did the play jouer? No, it was played. -> vu is invariant.) |
19
Think of this as a flowchart. You find the COD, you find the infinitive, and you ask if the first does the second. This simple test works for nearly every situation you'll encounter with this structure. It transforms a seemingly complex rule into a straightforward logical puzzle.

When To Use It

This grammatical pattern isn't used with all verbs. It's most frequently, and most importantly, associated with a specific set of verbs related to perception and causation.
1. Verbs of Perception (Sensory Verbs)
This is the classic and most common category. When you describe witnessing an action, you'll use this structure. The main verbs are:
  • voir (to see)
  • entendre (to hear)
  • écouter (to listen to)
  • regarder (to watch)
  • sentir (to feel/to smell)
Examples:
  • Je les ai vus voler une voiture. (I saw them steal a car. les refers to people who are stealing, so vus agrees.)
  • C'est une odeur que j'ai souvent senti se répandre dans la cuisine. (It's a smell I often smelled spreading in the kitchen. The smell se répandre (spreads itself), so senti is often seen as agreeing here. This is a subtle case, but typically follows the rule: if the verb is pronominal, agreement is common.) A clearer NO case: La lavande que j'ai senti couper. (The lavender isn't cutting, it is being cut -> invariant senti.)
2. The Verb laisser (To Let / To Allow)
The verb laisser also follows this logic perfectly. When you

Agreement Logic Table

Direct Object Infinitive Agent Agreement Example
Agent
Yes
Yes
La fille que j'ai vue chanter
Patient
No
No
La chanson que j'ai entendu chanter
N/A
N/A
Never (fait)
La voiture que j'ai fait réparer

Meanings

This rule dictates whether the past participle (like 'entendu' or 'vu') should change its ending to match the gender and number of the direct object when an infinitive follows.

1

Perception Verbs

Using verbs like 'entendre' (hear), 'voir' (see), or 'sentir' (feel) followed by an infinitive.

“La fille que j'ai vue danser.”

“Les oiseaux que j'ai entendus chanter.”

2

Causative 'Faire'

The specific case of 'faire' + infinitive.

“La voiture que j'ai fait réparer.”

“Les photos que j'ai fait imprimer.”

Reference Table

Reference table for French Past Participle Agreement with Infinitives (entendu chanter)
Form Structure Example
Affirmative
DO + avoir + Participle + Inf
La fille que j'ai vue danser
Negative
DO + ne + avoir + pas + Participle + Inf
La fille que je n'ai pas vue danser
Question
DO + avoir + Sujet + Participle + Inf
La fille que as-tu vue danser ?
Causative
DO + avoir + fait + Inf
La voiture que j'ai fait réparer
No Agreement
DO (Patient) + avoir + Participle + Inf
La chanson que j'ai entendu chanter

Formality Spectrum

Formal
La jeune fille que j'ai vue danser.

La jeune fille que j'ai vue danser. (Social observation)

Neutral
La fille que j'ai vue danser.

La fille que j'ai vue danser. (Social observation)

Informal
La fille que j'ai vue danser.

La fille que j'ai vue danser. (Social observation)

Slang
La meuf que j'ai vue danser.

La meuf que j'ai vue danser. (Social observation)

The Agreement Decision Tree

1

Is the verb 'faire'?

YES
No agreement
NO
Check agent
2

Is the DO the agent of the infinitive?

YES
Agree!
NO
No agreement

Examples by Level

1

La fille que j'ai vue danser.

The girl I saw dancing.

2

Les garçons que j'ai vus jouer.

The boys I saw playing.

3

La chanson que j'ai entendu chanter.

The song I heard sung.

4

Les devoirs que j'ai fait faire.

The homework I had done.

1

Les oiseaux que j'ai entendus chanter.

The birds I heard singing.

2

La voiture que j'ai fait réparer.

The car I had repaired.

3

Les photos que j'ai vues prendre.

The photos I saw being taken.

4

La femme que j'ai vue partir.

The woman I saw leaving.

1

Les musiciens que j'ai entendus jouer.

The musicians I heard playing.

2

La maison que j'ai fait construire.

The house I had built.

3

Les acteurs que j'ai vus jouer.

The actors I saw acting.

4

La lettre que j'ai fait écrire.

The letter I had written.

1

Les manifestants que j'ai vus défiler.

The protesters I saw marching.

2

Les rapports que j'ai fait imprimer.

The reports I had printed.

3

La danseuse que j'ai vue s'entraîner.

The dancer I saw training.

4

Les erreurs que j'ai fait corriger.

The errors I had corrected.

1

Les enfants que j'ai entendus pleurer.

The children I heard crying.

2

Les meubles que j'ai fait livrer.

The furniture I had delivered.

3

La mélodie que j'ai entendu jouer.

The melody I heard played.

4

Les témoins que j'ai vus témoigner.

The witnesses I saw testifying.

1

Les poèmes que j'ai entendu réciter.

The poems I heard recited.

2

Les travaux que j'ai fait achever.

The works I had finished.

3

La foule que j'ai vue acclamer.

The crowd I saw cheering.

4

Les plans que j'ai fait modifier.

The plans I had modified.

Easily Confused

French Past Participle Agreement with Infinitives (entendu chanter) vs Simple Past Participle Agreement

Learners confuse this with the infinitive rule.

French Past Participle Agreement with Infinitives (entendu chanter) vs Reflexive Verbs

Learners try to apply the infinitive rule to reflexives.

French Past Participle Agreement with Infinitives (entendu chanter) vs Faire + Infinitive

Learners try to agree 'fait'.

Common Mistakes

La fille que j'ai vu danser.

La fille que j'ai vue danser.

The girl is the agent.

Les chansons que j'ai entendues chanter.

Les chansons que j'ai entendu chanter.

The song is not the agent.

Les maisons que j'ai faites construire.

Les maisons que j'ai fait construire.

Fait never agrees.

La femme que j'ai vue partir.

La femme que j'ai vue partir.

Wait, this is correct, but learners often forget the 'e'.

Les photos que j'ai vues prendre.

Les photos que j'ai vu prendre.

Photos don't take themselves.

La voiture que j'ai faite réparer.

La voiture que j'ai fait réparer.

Fait is invariable.

Les oiseaux que j'ai entendu chanter.

Les oiseaux que j'ai entendus chanter.

Birds are the agents.

Les rapports que j'ai faits imprimer.

Les rapports que j'ai fait imprimer.

Fait is invariable.

La danseuse que j'ai vu s'entraîner.

La danseuse que j'ai vue s'entraîner.

She is the agent.

Les erreurs que j'ai faites corriger.

Les erreurs que j'ai fait corriger.

Fait is invariable.

Les poèmes que j'ai entendus réciter.

Les poèmes que j'ai entendu réciter.

Poems are not agents.

La foule que j'ai vue acclamer.

La foule que j'ai vue acclamer.

Crowd is the agent.

Les plans que j'ai faits modifier.

Les plans que j'ai fait modifier.

Fait is invariable.

Sentence Patterns

La ___ que j'ai vue ___.

Les ___ que j'ai vus ___.

La ___ que j'ai fait ___.

Les ___ que j'ai entendu ___.

Real World Usage

Social Media common

La vidéo que j'ai vue tourner sur Twitter.

Job Interview common

Les projets que j'ai fait aboutir.

Travel occasional

Les monuments que j'ai vu construire.

Food Delivery occasional

Le repas que j'ai fait livrer.

Texting constant

La fille que j'ai vue danser !

Academic Writing very common

Les théories que j'ai entendu exposer.

💡

The Agent Test

Always ask: 'Is the object doing the action?' If yes, agree.
⚠️

Faire is special

Never add an 'e' or 's' to 'fait' when an infinitive follows.
🎯

Listen for the sound

The agreement is invisible in speech, so focus on writing it correctly.
💬

Casual vs Formal

In casual settings, people often skip this agreement, but don't do it in exams.

Smart Tips

Pause and ask: 'Who is doing the action?'

La fille que j'ai vu danser. La fille que j'ai vue danser.

Remember 'fait' is always invariable.

Les maisons que j'ai faites construire. Les maisons que j'ai fait construire.

Check if the object is the agent.

Les oiseaux que j'ai entendu chanter. Les oiseaux que j'ai entendus chanter.

Always double-check your agreements.

Les rapports que j'ai fait imprimer. Les rapports que j'ai fait imprimer (Correct).

Pronunciation

vu / vus (same sound)

Agreement endings

The 'e' or 's' does not change the pronunciation of the participle.

Rising for questions

La fille que j'ai vue danser ? ↗

Clarification

Memorize It

Mnemonic

Agent = Agree. Patient = Pass (no agreement).

Visual Association

Imagine a girl singing (she is the agent, so she gets an 'e'). Imagine a song being sung (the song is just a thing, so it gets no 'e').

Rhyme

If the object does the deed, add an 'e' to match the speed.

Story

I saw the ballerina (she is dancing, so 'vue'). I saw the ballet (the ballet is just a show, so 'vu'). I had the costume made (always 'fait').

Word Web

entenduvufaitagentpatientinfinitive

Challenge

Write three sentences: one where the object is an agent, one where it is a patient, and one using 'faire'.

Cultural Notes

In France, this rule is strictly taught in schools and expected in formal writing.

Similar to France, though casual speech often drops agreement.

Follows standard French rules closely.

This rule evolved from the Latin past participle, which functioned as an adjective.

Conversation Starters

Quel est le dernier concert que tu as vu jouer ?

As-tu déjà fait réparer ta voiture ?

Quelles chansons as-tu entendu chanter récemment ?

As-tu déjà fait construire quelque chose ?

Journal Prompts

Describe a concert you attended.
Write about a home renovation project.
Discuss a performance that moved you.
Reflect on a professional project you managed.

Common Mistakes

Incorrect

Correct


Incorrect

Correct


Incorrect

Correct


Incorrect

Correct

Test Yourself

Fill in the correct form of the participle.

La fille que j'ai ____ (voir) danser.

✓ Correct! ✗ Not quite. Correct answer: vue
The girl is the agent.
Choose the correct sentence. Multiple Choice

Which is correct?

✓ Correct! ✗ Not quite. Correct answer: La chanson que j'ai entendu chanter.
The song is not the agent.
Correct the mistake. Error Correction

Find and fix the mistake:

Les maisons que j'ai faites construire.

✓ Correct! ✗ Not quite. Correct answer: Les maisons que j'ai fait construire.
Fait is invariable.
Reorder the words. Sentence Reorder

Arrange the words in the correct order:

All words placed

Click words above to build the sentence

✓ Correct! ✗ Not quite. Correct answer: La fille que j'ai vue danser.
Correct word order.
Translate to French. Translation

The boys I saw playing.

Answer starts with: Les...

✓ Correct! ✗ Not quite. Correct answer: Les garçons que j'ai vus jouer.
Boys are the agents.
Complete the dialogue. Dialogue Completion

A: Tu as vu la danseuse ? B: Oui, la danseuse que j'ai ____ danser.

✓ Correct! ✗ Not quite. Correct answer: vue
The dancer is the agent.
Build a sentence. Sentence Building

Use: les photos, j'ai, voir, prendre.

✓ Correct! ✗ Not quite. Correct answer: Les photos que j'ai vues prendre.
Photos are the agents of being taken.
Sort by agreement. Grammar Sorting

Which requires agreement?

✓ Correct! ✗ Not quite. Correct answer: La fille que j'ai vue danser.
Only the girl is the agent.

Score: /8

Practice Exercises

8 exercises
Fill in the correct form of the participle.

La fille que j'ai ____ (voir) danser.

✓ Correct! ✗ Not quite. Correct answer: vue
The girl is the agent.
Choose the correct sentence. Multiple Choice

Which is correct?

✓ Correct! ✗ Not quite. Correct answer: La chanson que j'ai entendu chanter.
The song is not the agent.
Correct the mistake. Error Correction

Find and fix the mistake:

Les maisons que j'ai faites construire.

✓ Correct! ✗ Not quite. Correct answer: Les maisons que j'ai fait construire.
Fait is invariable.
Reorder the words. Sentence Reorder

que / j'ai / vue / la / danser / fille

✓ Correct! ✗ Not quite. Correct answer: La fille que j'ai vue danser.
Correct word order.
Translate to French. Translation

The boys I saw playing.

✓ Correct! ✗ Not quite. Correct answer: Les garçons que j'ai vus jouer.
Boys are the agents.
Complete the dialogue. Dialogue Completion

A: Tu as vu la danseuse ? B: Oui, la danseuse que j'ai ____ danser.

✓ Correct! ✗ Not quite. Correct answer: vue
The dancer is the agent.
Build a sentence. Sentence Building

Use: les photos, j'ai, voir, prendre.

✓ Correct! ✗ Not quite. Correct answer: Les photos que j'ai vues prendre.
Photos are the agents of being taken.
Sort by agreement. Grammar Sorting

Which requires agreement?

✓ Correct! ✗ Not quite. Correct answer: La fille que j'ai vue danser.
Only the girl is the agent.

Score: /8

Practice Bank

10 exercises
Fill in the blank Fill in the Blank

Les acteurs que j'ai _____ (voir) jouer étaient nuls.

✓ Correct! ✗ Not quite. Correct answer: vus
Correct the agreement Error Correction

Les lettres que j'ai fait écrire sont sur la table.

✓ Correct! ✗ Not quite. Correct answer: Les lettres que j'ai fait écrire sont sur la table.
Select the correct form Multiple Choice

Ma sœur, je l'ai _____ (entendre) pleurer.

✓ Correct! ✗ Not quite. Correct answer: entendue
Put the words in order Sentence Reorder

heard / I / singing / her / .

✓ Correct! ✗ Not quite. Correct answer: Je l'ai entendue chanter .
Translate to French Translation

The flowers I saw growing.

✓ Correct! ✗ Not quite. Correct answer: Les fleurs que j'ai vues pousser.
Match the logic to the example Match Pairs

Match the reason to the correct sentence:

✓ Correct! ✗ Not quite. Correct answer: Object does action: Les chiens que j'ai vus courir.
Fill in the blank Fill in the Blank

Les oiseaux, je les ai _____ (écouter) chanter.

✓ Correct! ✗ Not quite. Correct answer: écoutés
Which one uses the modern rule? Multiple Choice

Modern French allows no agreement for this verb:

✓ Correct! ✗ Not quite. Correct answer: Laisser
Fix the sentence Error Correction

Les pommes que j'ai vues manger étaient rouges.

✓ Correct! ✗ Not quite. Correct answer: Les pommes que j'ai vu manger étaient rouges.
Translate to French Translation

I had them come (masculine plural).

✓ Correct! ✗ Not quite. Correct answer: Je les ai fait venir.

Score: /10

FAQ (8)

It is treated as part of a compound verb with the infinitive.

The agreement is silent, so it's only visible in writing.

The same rules apply; check if the person is the agent.

Yes, like 'voir', 'entendre', 'sentir'.

Yes, it's common in informal texting.

Ask: 'Is the object doing the action of the infinitive?'

Only 'faire' is a major exception.

Yes, it only happens with 'avoir'.

Scaffolded Practice

1

1

2

2

3

3

4

4

Mastery Progress

Needs Practice

Improving

Strong

Mastered

In Other Languages

Spanish moderate

He visto a la chica bailar.

Spanish does not agree the participle in this context.

German low

Ich habe das Mädchen tanzen sehen.

German lacks this specific agreement mechanism.

Japanese none

私は少女が踊るのを見た。

Japanese has no gender or number agreement.

Arabic none

رأيت الفتاة ترقص.

Arabic does not have this participle agreement.

Chinese none

我看见那个女孩跳舞。

Chinese has no verb agreement.

English low

I saw the girl dancing.

English has no participle agreement.

Learning Path

Prerequisites

Was this helpful?

Comments (0)

Login to Comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!