Relative Pronouns: 'Which' for Things
Grammar Rule in 30 Seconds
Use 'which' to give more information about objects, animals, or ideas without starting a new sentence.
- Use 'which' only for things and animals, never for people. Example: 'The book which I read.'
- In non-defining clauses (extra info), always use a comma before 'which'. Example: 'My car, which is old, broke.'
- In defining clauses (essential info), 'which' can often be replaced by 'that' in informal English.
Overview
You want to tell more about a thing. You can use one sentence. Use a word to connect ideas.
Use "which" for things or animals. It helps people know what you mean. It makes your talk clear.
Now, use "which" for important details. These details show exactly what you mean. The sentence needs these details.
Use "which" to write well. You do not need to say words twice. Your talk will be clear.
How This Grammar Works
- When
whichis the subject, it performs the action of the verb in the relative clause. For instance, inThe car which broke down was old,whichis the subject ofbroke down. - When
whichis the object, it receives the action of the verb in the relative clause, and there will be a separate subject performing the action. For example, inThe film which I watched last night was excellent,Iis the subject ofwatched, andwhichis the object ofwatched. Understanding this distinction is crucial because it affects whetherwhichcan be omitted, as you will see later.
Formation Pattern
The new phone which has a great camera is very popular. (Here, which is the subject of has).
The old building which stands on the hill is a museum. (which is the subject of stands).
The idea which seemed revolutionary failed to gain support. (which is the subject of seemed).
This is the presentation which I prepared for the meeting. (You prepared which).
The tools which we used were borrowed from a friend. (We used which).
The issue about which we are concerned is urgent.
The issue which we are concerned about is urgent.
This is the chair in which I found the old coins.
This is the chair which I found the old coins in.
When To Use It
I need the document which was signed yesterday.(There might be many documents, but you need the specific one signed yesterday).She chose the dress which had embroidered flowers.(Not just any dress, but the one with a particular design).The application which crashed earlier is working now.(Identifying the specific application that caused a problem).
He bought a new software which helps manage his finances.(The software's function is key to understanding its value).They visited a museum which displayed modern art from the 20th century.(The type of art is essential context for the museum).I admire her ability to solve problems which others find impossible.(The difficulty of the problems defines her ability).
Common Mistakes
which for People:- Incorrect:
My friend which lives in London is visiting next week. - Correct:
My friend who lives in London is visiting next week. - Incorrect:
The doctor which treated me was very kind. - Correct:
The doctor who treated me was very kind.
Whichas object (can be omitted):The book (which) I read was excellent.(Here,Iis the subject ofread,whichis the object. Omission is possible.)The car (which) they bought is red.(theyis the subject ofbought,whichis the object. Omission is possible.)Whichas subject (cannot be omitted):- Incorrect:
The device needs repair has a broken screen.(This sentence is missing a subject forneeds repair.) - Correct:
The device which needs repair has a broken screen.(whichis the subject ofneeds repair). - Incorrect:
The dog is barking is a golden retriever.(Missing a subject foris barking.) - Correct:
The dog which is barking is a golden retriever.
- Ambiguous:
I saw a man with a telescope which was looking at the moon.(Was the man looking at the moon, or was the telescope looking at the moon?) - Clearer:
I saw a man who was looking at the moon with a telescope.(If the man was looking). - Clearer:
I saw a man with a telescope which had powerful lenses.(If the telescope had powerful lenses).
The computer which crashed lost all my data.(Correct,whichis fine.)The computer that crashed lost all my data.(Correct,thatis also fine here.)
which with whose:- Incorrect:
The car which owner is famous is parked outside. - Correct:
The car whose owner is famous is parked outside. - Correct:
The car which is parked outside belongs to a famous owner.
Real Conversations
Which is a cornerstone of natural English, allowing speakers to communicate detailed information efficiently. Observing its use in everyday contexts demonstrates its versatility and importance.
In Casual Conversation/Texting:
You'll use which constantly to elaborate on things you're discussing, making your messages more informative without being clunky.
- "Did you watch that new series which everyone's recommending? The one which has all the time travel?"
- "I need to fix the bike which I lent you. The chain which broke was brand new."
- "My favorite cafe, which is near the park, makes the best coffee."
- "Found this amazing recipe which uses only five ingredients. So easy!"
In Professional or Academic Settings:
Which enables precise descriptions and specifications, crucial for clarity in reports, presentations, and discussions.
- "We need to analyze the data which was collected last quarter."
- "The proposal which outlines the project scope requires your immediate review."
- "Could you provide the feedback which relates to the user interface?"
- "The research methodology, which was developed over several months, ensures reliability."
On Social Media/Online Forums:
When describing experiences, products, or opinions, which helps users add context and detail effectively.
- "Just tried a new restaurant which serves incredible vegan dishes! Highly recommend it." (Instagram caption)
- "Anyone know a good app which helps with learning languages? Looking for one which tracks progress effectively." (Online forum query)
- "This documentary, which exposes the issues with fast fashion, really changed my perspective." (Tweet)
- "Reading a book which challenges conventional wisdom on economic growth." (LinkedIn post)
These examples highlight how which seamlessly integrates descriptive clauses into sentences, making communication richer and more detailed across various communication channels. It allows for the expression of complex thoughts in a clear, concise manner, reflecting how native speakers build coherent narratives.
Quick FAQ
- Q: Can I always use
thatinstead ofwhichfor things? - A: In defining relative clauses (where the information is essential),
thatcan often replacewhich. For example,The car which I boughtis synonymous withThe car that I bought. However,whichis sometimes preferred in formal writing, andthatcannot be used in non-defining clauses (those set off by commas, providing extra, non-essential information), which are typically introduced bywhich. At the B1 level, you can generally use either in defining clauses for things, but rememberwhichis always correct.
- Q: Does
whichalways follow the noun directly? - A: Yes, for clarity, the relative clause introduced by
whichshould follow the noun it describes as immediately as possible. Placing other words or phrases between the noun and its relative clause can lead to ambiguity about whatwhichrefers to. For example,I saw a man with a dog which was barkingis clearer thanI saw a man which was barking with a dog.
- Q: What's the main difference between
whoandwhich? - A: The distinction is based on whether you are referring to a person or a thing/animal/idea. Use
whofor people (e.g.,The student who aced the exam), and usewhichfor things, animals, and abstract ideas (e.g.,The computer which crashed). This is a fundamental rule for correct relative pronoun usage.
- Q: Can
whichbe used with prepositions? - A: Yes. You can use the formal structure
preposition + which(e.g.,The topic about which we spoke). In everyday, informal English, it is much more common to place the preposition at the end of the relative clause (e.g.,The topic which we spoke about). Both are grammatically correct, but the latter is more frequently encountered in conversational contexts.
- Q: Is a comma always needed before
which? - A: No, not always. For defining relative clauses (the focus at B1), which provide essential information, you typically do not use a comma before
which. Commas are used for non-defining relative clauses, which give additional, non-essential information and can be removed without changing the core meaning of the sentence. Since your primary use ofwhichat this level will be in defining clauses, you will often find no comma before it.
- Q: What if the clause refers to an entire previous clause or idea, not just a single noun?
- A: This is a more advanced usage, but
whichcan sometimes refer to a whole preceding statement or idea. For example,He passed the exam, which surprised everyone.Here,whichrefers to the fact that "he passed the exam." This is typically a non-defining clause and thus requires a comma. While common, focus first onwhichmodifying a specific noun.
- Q: Can I use
whichwhen talking about a group that includes both people and things? - A: When a relative clause modifies a combined antecedent of people and things (e.g.,
the students and their projects),thatis often preferred or used as a neutral choice. For example,I saw the students and their projects that won awards.If you want to specify the things, you might rephrase or use separate clauses for clarity.
Using 'Which' in Different Roles
| Role | Structure | Example | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Subject
|
Noun + which + Verb
|
The car which crashed...
|
'Which' acts as the subject.
|
|
Object
|
Noun + which + Subject + Verb
|
The car which I bought...
|
'Which' acts as the object.
|
|
With Preposition (Formal)
|
Noun + Prep + which + Subj + Verb
|
The house in which I live...
|
Common in formal writing.
|
|
With Preposition (Informal)
|
Noun + which + Subj + Verb + Prep
|
The house which I live in...
|
Common in spoken English.
|
|
Sentential
|
Clause + , + which + Verb
|
It rained, which was bad.
|
Refers to the whole situation.
|
Meanings
A relative pronoun used to introduce a relative clause that provides additional information about a noun that is not a person (objects, animals, concepts, or whole situations).
Defining Relative Clause
Used to identify exactly which object we are talking about. The information is essential to the sentence.
“The umbrella which I lost yesterday was blue.”
“Where is the letter which arrived this morning?”
Non-Defining Relative Clause
Used to add extra, non-essential information about an object. It is always separated by commas.
“My house, which was built in 1920, needs repairs.”
“The movie, which lasted three hours, was very boring.”
Sentential Relative Clause
Used to refer back to the entire previous clause or sentence rather than just a single noun.
“He arrived late, which annoyed everyone.”
“She passed the exam, which was a huge relief.”
Reference Table
| Form | Structure | Example |
|---|---|---|
|
Defining (Essential)
|
Noun + which + Clause
|
The book which is on the table is mine.
|
|
Non-Defining (Extra)
|
Noun + , which + Clause + ,
|
My car, which is old, still works.
|
|
Negative
|
Noun + which + do/be + not + Verb
|
The plan which didn't work was expensive.
|
|
Question
|
Is this the noun + which + ...?
|
Is this the phone which you lost?
|
|
Possessive (Formal)
|
Noun + of which + ...
|
The house, the roof of which is red...
|
|
Sentential
|
Sentence + , which + Verb
|
She won, which was amazing.
|
Formality Spectrum
The vehicle which was acquired last month is performing well. (Purchasing a car)
The car which I bought last month is running great. (Purchasing a car)
The car I got last month is great. (Purchasing a car)
That ride which I copped is fire. (Purchasing a car)
The World of 'Which'
Usage
- Objects The table which...
- Animals The cat which...
- Ideas The theory which...
Types
- Defining Essential info
- Non-defining Extra info (commas)
Who vs. Which
Choosing Between Which and That
Is the info essential?
Is it after a comma?
Common Antecedents for 'Which'
Technology
- • Laptop
- • Software
- • App
Nature
- • Tree
- • River
- • Weather
Examples by Level
I have a car which is red.
This is the book which I like.
The dog which is in the garden is mine.
I want the cake which has chocolate.
The phone which I bought yesterday is broken.
Is this the bus which goes to the airport?
I lost the keys which were on the table.
The movie which we saw was very funny.
My computer, which is quite old, is very slow.
He forgot my birthday, which made me sad.
The hotel which we stayed in was near the beach.
I need a job which allows me to work from home.
The document to which you are referring is lost.
The city, which was founded in 1200, is famous for its art.
They offered me a promotion, which I immediately accepted.
The criteria by which we judge success are changing.
The proposal, the merits of which are debatable, was rejected.
He was late for the meeting, which fact he failed to mention.
The system, which had been failing for years, finally collapsed.
It was a decision from which there was no turning back.
The treaty, the signing of which heralded a new era, was brief.
She argued that the law was unjust, which view was widely shared.
The company went bankrupt, which outcome surprised no one.
We reached the summit at noon, by which time the fog had lifted.
Easily Confused
Learners often use 'that' after a comma or 'which' without a comma when they shouldn't.
Using 'which' for people or 'who' for objects.
Using 'what' to join two sentences.
Common Mistakes
The man which is tall.
The man who is tall.
The book it is good.
The book which is good.
I like the cat who is black.
I like the cat which is black.
The car which it is red.
The car which is red.
The movie what I saw.
The movie which I saw.
The pen which I write with it.
The pen which I write with.
The house where I bought.
The house which I bought.
My car, that is old, broke down.
My car, which is old, broke down.
He was late that was annoying.
He was late, which was annoying.
The city which I live is big.
The city which I live in is big.
The company who's profits are high.
The company, the profits of which are high.
Sentence Patterns
I have a ___ which ___.
The ___ which I ___ is ___.
My ___, which is ___, is ___.
___, which meant that ___.
Real World Usage
I want to return the shoes which I ordered last week.
I am looking for a role which offers growth opportunities.
I lost my phone, which is why I didn't call.
Is this the museum which has the Picasso paintings?
Click the button which is located in the top right corner.
Check out this sunset, which was taken without a filter!
The Comma Test
No 'Which' for People
Omission
Which vs That
Smart Tips
Use 'which' instead of 'that' to sound more professional and precise.
Use ', which' at the end of your sentence to share your opinion.
Never use 'that' after a comma in a relative clause. It's always 'which'.
Try removing 'which' to see if the sentence sounds more natural in speech.
Pronunciation
The 'wh' sound
In most modern English dialects, 'which' is pronounced exactly like 'witch' /wɪtʃ/. Some older or regional dialects (like Scottish) might use a voiceless 'w' /hw/.
Comma Intonation
In non-defining clauses, there is a slight drop in pitch and a brief pause where the commas are.
Non-defining drop
The cake, ↘ which was chocolate, ↗ was eaten.
The information inside the commas is parenthetical (extra).
Memorize It
Mnemonic
W-H-I-C-H: Whatever Has Inanimate Characteristics Here.
Visual Association
Imagine a giant question mark (?) turning into a bridge. The bridge connects a box (the object) to a label (the description). The bridge is made of the letters W-H-I-C-H.
Rhyme
For a person use 'who', for a thing 'which' will do.
Story
A robot named 'Which' only collects objects. He picks up a 'ball which is round' and a 'box which is heavy'. He never picks up people because he doesn't understand 'who' they are.
Word Web
Challenge
Look around your room. Pick 5 objects and describe them using 'which'. (e.g., 'The chair which is near the window is brown.')
Cultural Notes
American style guides (like APA or Chicago) are very strict about using 'that' for defining clauses and 'which' only for non-defining clauses.
British English is more flexible. It is very common to hear 'which' used in defining clauses where an American would almost always use 'that'.
In academic writing globally, 'which' is preferred for its precision, especially when used with prepositions like 'in which' or 'by which'.
From Old English 'hwilc', which was originally a question word meaning 'of what form'.
Conversation Starters
What is a movie which you have seen many times?
Tell me about a hobby which you started recently.
Describe a city which you would love to visit.
Think of a problem in your town which needs to be fixed.
Journal Prompts
Common Mistakes
Test Yourself
The car ___ I bought is very fast.
Find and fix the mistake:
The man which lives next door is a doctor.
My bike ___ is in the garage is broken.
I have a new phone. It has a great camera.
Paris, that is the capital of France, is beautiful.
A: Why are you upset? B: I lost my wallet, ___.
Select the non-defining clause.
Match each item on the left with its pair on the right:
Score: /8
Practice Exercises
8 exercisesThe car ___ I bought is very fast.
Find and fix the mistake:
The man which lives next door is a doctor.
My bike ___ is in the garage is broken.
I have a new phone. It has a great camera.
Paris, that is the capital of France, is beautiful.
A: Why are you upset? B: I lost my wallet, ___.
Select the non-defining clause.
1. The house... 2. He lied... 3. The dog...
Score: /8
Practice Bank
13 exercisesThe laptop ___ I use for work is very fast.
Choose the correct sentence:
Do you know the café ___ has outdoor seating?
Match the subjects with the correct form:
The movie, who was nominated for an Oscar, is streaming now.
Translate into English: 'Ella tiene un perro que siempre duerme en su cama.'
Arrange these words into a sentence:
The concept ___ he explained was quite complex.
I found the keys was under the couch.
Arrange these words into a sentence:
Translate into English: 'El software, sin el cual no podemos operar, requiere una actualización.'
Which sentence is correct?
The painting, you bought, is beautiful.
Score: /13
FAQ (8)
No, 'which' is strictly for things, animals, and ideas. For people, always use `who` or `whom`.
Use a comma if the information is 'extra' (non-defining). If the information is essential to identify the object, don't use a comma.
In American English, `that` is preferred for essential information. In British English, both are fine. However, only `which` can be used for extra information after a comma.
Yes, but only if it is the object of the clause (e.g., 'The book (which) I bought'). If it is the subject (e.g., 'The book which is on the table'), you must keep it.
It's when `which` refers to the whole previous sentence, not just one word. Example: 'He won, which surprised us.'
Yes, 'which' is the standard pronoun for animals. However, if the animal is a pet with a name, many people use `who`.
It is slightly more formal than `that` in defining clauses, but it is neutral in most other contexts.
It is a formal way to show possession for things. Example: 'The car, the door of which was open...' (Instead of 'whose door').
Scaffolded Practice
1
2
3
4
Mastery Progress
Needs Practice
Improving
Strong
Mastered
In Other Languages
que / el cual
English distinguishes between 'who' (people) and 'which' (things), whereas Spanish often uses 'que' for both.
qui / que / lequel
French relative pronouns change based on grammatical function (subject/object) rather than person/thing.
der / die / das / welcher
German relative pronouns have gender (masculine/feminine/neuter), while English 'which' is gender-neutral.
Attributive form
Japanese uses word order (modifier before noun) instead of a connecting word like 'which'.
al-ladhi (الذي)
English 'which' is much simpler as it doesn't change for number or gender.
de (的)
The structure is reversed: [Description] + de + [Noun].
Learning Path
Prerequisites
Related Videos
The Land Your State Doesn't Control
The Biggest Eruptions That Changed Earth Forever
You Are Not Where You Think You Are
RELATIVE PRONOUNS | RELATIVE CLAUSES | ADJECTIVE CLAUSES - who, which, that, whose, whom
Arnel's Everyday English
WHICH or THAT? A quick and simple guide. Relative clauses explained. English grammar lesson
To The Point English with Ben.
Relative Pronouns | Learn Basic English
English Animated
Related Grammar Rules
Relative Clauses: Defining vs Non-Defining Meaning
Overview Relative clauses function as modifiers, providing additional information about a noun or pronoun. English gramm...
Relative Adverb: Where for Places
Overview The relative adverb `where` is a fundamental tool for B1 English learners to construct more sophisticated and c...
Formal Relative Clauses (in which, to whom)
Overview Formal relative clauses, which follow the structure **`preposition + which`** or **`preposition + whom`**, are...
Shorten Your Sentences: Reduced Relative Clauses
Overview Reduced relative clauses are a powerful tool for making your English more concise, fluent, and sophisticated. T...
Whose: Showing Possession
Overview `Whose` is the primary **possessive relative pronoun** in English. Its core function is to connect a noun in a...