관계대명사: 사물에 대한 'Which'
which를 사용해 보세요.
Grammar Rule in 30 Seconds
Use 'which' to give more information about objects, animals, or ideas without starting a new sentence.
- Use 'which' only for things and animals, never for people. Example: 'The book which I read.'
- In non-defining clauses (extra info), always use a comma before 'which'. Example: 'My car, which is old, broke.'
- In defining clauses (essential info), 'which' can often be replaced by 'that' in informal English.
Overview
which가 필요해.which를 사용하는 건 명사에 특별한 풍미를 더하는 것과 같아. 문법적으로는 관계대명사라고 부르지만, 그냥 '포인터(pointer)'라고 생각해도 돼. who가 네 친구들이나 가족에게만 쓰인다면, which는 그 외의 모든 것들—네 아이폰, 동네 길고양이, 월요일 아침에 느끼는 존재론적 공포, 또는 계속 생각나는 틱톡 영상 같은 것들을 담당하거든.which는 우리가 정확히 어떤 것을 말하고 있는지 정의하거나, 꼭 필요하지는 않지만 알아두면 재미있는 '보너스' 사실을 덧붙일 때 사용해. 게시물의 '수정' 버튼 같은 거지.How This Grammar Works
which는 명사를 대신해. 문장의 두 번째 부분에서 명사를 반복하는 대신 which로 바꾸는 거지. 예를 들어 «노트북이 탁자 위에 있어»와 «그 노트북은 고장 났어»라는 두 생각이 있다고 해보자.the laptop을 반복하는 대신 그 노트북은,라고 말하는 거야. 어때? 훨씬 매끄럽지?which탁자 위에 있는데, 고장 났어(The laptop,whichis on the table, is broken).
내가 어제 산 그 게임(which I bought yesterday) 진짜 대박이야. 두 번째는 없어도 상관없는 추가 정보를 더하는 '계속적(non-defining)' 버전이야.내 차는, which 10년이나 됐는데, 아직도 쌩쌩해. 여기 콤마(,) 보여? 이 콤마들은 마치 손잡이 같아서, 원한다면 추가 정보를 들어서 던져버릴 수도 있다는 뜻이야. 만약 정보가 그냥 '참고로 말하자면' 같은 느낌이라면 콤마를 써.which는 때때로 상황 전체를 가리킬 수도 있어. 걔가 내 생일을 잊어버렸어, which 진짜 짜증 났어. 여기서 which는 그냥 생일이 아니라, 걔가 생일을 잊어버렸다는 '사실'을 말하는 거야.Formation Pattern
which로 문장을 만드는 건 레고 세트를 조립하는 것과 같아. 순서만 잘 따르면 돼:
which를 넣어.
그 피자는 (1),which(3) 파인애플이 올라가 있었는데 (4), 맛있었어 (6).
which가 이끄는 절은 명사와 최대한 가까이 있어야 해. 너무 멀리 떨어뜨려 놓으면 사람들이 네가 뭘 설명하는지 헷갈릴 수 있거든. 나는 파란색이었던(which was blue) 차 안에 있는 고양이를 봤어라고 말하지 마. 고양이가 파란색이었을까, 차가 파란색이었을까? 아바타 고양이가 아니라면, 아마 차가 파란색이었다는 뜻이겠지?
When To Use It
which를 써봐. 이럴 때 딱이야:- 소셜 미디어 캡션:
그 풍경은,
which내 숨을 멎게 했는데, 하이킹할 가치가 있었어. - 제품 리뷰:
그 헤드폰은,
which아마존에서 주문했는데, 망가진 채로 왔어. - 업무용 이메일:
그 보고서는,
which최종 데이터를 포함하고 있는데, 아래에 첨부되어 있습니다. - 스토리텔링:
우리는 예전에 유령 성이었던
which호텔에서 묵었어. - 선택지 명확히 하기:
네가 보고 싶어 했던 영화가
(잠깐,which어떤 거야?which가 두 번이나 들어갔네! 문법적으로는 문제없지만, 좀 반복적일 수 있으니 하나는that으로 바꿔서 더 자연스럽게 말해봐.)
that이 정말 흔하지만, which는 '논문을 쓰는 대학생'이나 '발표하는 CEO' 같은 느낌을 주거든. 공식적인 편지나 에세이를 쓴다면 which가 네 최고의 친구가 될 거야. 문자 메시지에서는? 쓸 수는 있지만 가볍게 유지해. 방금 쏟은 which 커피가 내 흰 셔츠에 다 묻었어. 망했다.Common Mistakes
- 사람 실수(The Human Error): 사람한테
which를 쓰는 것.친절한
✗ 땡!which선생님.who를 써야 해. 선생님이 홀로그램이 아닌 이상who를 써드릴 가치가 있어. - 콤마 트라우마(Comma Trauma): 추가 정보를 줄 때 콤마를 잊는 것.
삼성인 내 핸드폰
만약 핸드폰이 하나뿐이라면 콤마가 필요해:which은 새 거야.내 핸드폰은,
콤마가 없으면 핸드폰이 다섯 대쯤 있는데 그중 삼성 것을 특정하는 것처럼 들려.which삼성인데, 새 거야. - 이중 주어(The Double Subject): 대명사를 하나 더 추가하는 것.
내가 읽은 그 책
✗ 안 돼!which은 그것은 좋았어.which가 이미 '그것(it)'을 대신하고 있어. 대명사를 너무 욕심내지 마. - Which 대 What:
which대신what을 쓰는 것.내가 본 그 영화
✗ 이건 원어민 같지 않거나 아주 특이한 방언처럼 들려. 사물에는what.which나that을 쓰자. - 거리 문제(Distance Issues): 명사와
which사이에 너무 많은 단어를 넣는 것. 둘이 첫 데이트를 하는 것처럼 서로 아주 좋아해서 딱 붙어 있게 해 줘.
Contrast With Similar Patterns
which의 가장 큰 라이벌은 that이야. 많은 경우, 특히 미국 영어에서는 둘을 섞어서 써. 내가 원하는 그 차(that I want)와 내가 원하는 그 차(which I want) 둘 다 괜찮아. 하지만 비밀 규칙이 하나 있어: 콤마가 있는 '계속적 용법'에는 오직 which만 쓸 수 있어. 내 집은, that 빨간색인데, 모퉁이에 있어. ✗ 이건 그냥 이상하게 들려. 반드시 which를 써야 해.who야. 말했듯이 who는 사람용, which는 사물용이지. 동물은 좀 애매해. 네 반려견 '스파키'라면 who를 써줘. 가족이잖아! 하지만 공원에 있는 이름 모를 비둘기라면 which를 쓰는 게 맞아.where와 비교해 보자. where는 장소에 쓰지만, 전치사를 더하면 which도 장소에 쓸 수 있어. 내가 사는 그 집(where I live)은 내가 그 안에서 사는 그 집(in which I live)과 같아. 두 번째 표현은 드라마 '다운튼 애비' 같은 아주 격식 있는 느낌이야. 보통 사람들은 그냥 The house I live in이라고 말하지만, 품격 있는 느낌을 주고 싶을 땐
which가 아주 유용해.Quick FAQ
which로 질문을 시작할 수 있어?
응, 하지만 그건 역할이 달라!
어떤 걸 원해?(Which one do you want?)는 의문 대명사야. 여기서 우리가 배운
which는 문장을 이어주는 관계 대명사고.
which가 that보다 더 격식 있어?
대체로 그래. 일상적인 문자에서는 that을 쓰거나 대명사를 아예 생략하기도 해.
내가 읽은 책(The book I read)이
내가 읽은 which 그 책보다 훨씬 흔해.
which가 문장 전체를 가리킬 수 있어?
당연하지!
하루 종일 비가 왔어, which 우리 소풍을 망쳤지. 여기서 which는 비가 왔다는 사실 전체를 가리켜.
which 앞에는 항상 콤마가 필요해?
항상 그런 건 아냐. 정보가 '추가적'이고 그 내용이 없어도 문장이 말이 될 때만 콤마를 써.
회사에 대해 말할 때는 어떡해?
회사는 보통 '사물'로 취급하니까 which를 써.
그 회사는, which 2010년에 설립되었는데, 이제 세계적인 대기업이야.
반려동물한테 which를 써도 돼?
차갑고 거리감을 두고 싶다면 그래도 돼. 하지만 사랑한다면 who를 써줘!
Using 'Which' in Different Roles
| Role | Structure | Example | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Subject
|
Noun + which + Verb
|
The car which crashed...
|
'Which' acts as the subject.
|
|
Object
|
Noun + which + Subject + Verb
|
The car which I bought...
|
'Which' acts as the object.
|
|
With Preposition (Formal)
|
Noun + Prep + which + Subj + Verb
|
The house in which I live...
|
Common in formal writing.
|
|
With Preposition (Informal)
|
Noun + which + Subj + Verb + Prep
|
The house which I live in...
|
Common in spoken English.
|
|
Sentential
|
Clause + , + which + Verb
|
It rained, which was bad.
|
Refers to the whole situation.
|
Meanings
A relative pronoun used to introduce a relative clause that provides additional information about a noun that is not a person (objects, animals, concepts, or whole situations).
Defining Relative Clause
Used to identify exactly which object we are talking about. The information is essential to the sentence.
“The umbrella which I lost yesterday was blue.”
“Where is the letter which arrived this morning?”
Non-Defining Relative Clause
Used to add extra, non-essential information about an object. It is always separated by commas.
“My house, which was built in 1920, needs repairs.”
“The movie, which lasted three hours, was very boring.”
Sentential Relative Clause
Used to refer back to the entire previous clause or sentence rather than just a single noun.
“He arrived late, which annoyed everyone.”
“She passed the exam, which was a huge relief.”
Reference Table
| 대명사 | 지칭 대상 | 기능 | 예시 |
|---|---|---|---|
|
who
|
People
|
Subject/Object of relative clause
|
The student `who` passed.
|
|
which
|
Things, animals, ideas
|
Subject/Object of relative clause
|
The book `which` I read.
|
|
that
|
People, things, animals, ideas
|
Subject/Object of relative clause
|
The car `that` broke down.
|
|
whom
|
People (formal object)
|
Object of relative clause (formal)
|
The person `whom` I met.
|
|
whose
|
Possession (people/things)
|
Possessive
|
The artist `whose` work I admire.
|
격식 수준 스펙트럼
The vehicle which was acquired last month is performing well. (Purchasing a car)
The car which I bought last month is running great. (Purchasing a car)
The car I got last month is great. (Purchasing a car)
That ride which I copped is fire. (Purchasing a car)
"Which" 이해하기
지칭 대상
- Things 무생물
- Animals 반려동물, 야생동물
- Ideas 개념, 계획
기능
- Connects Clauses 설명 정보를 연결
- Adds Detail 필수 또는 부가 정보 제공
- Avoids Repetition 두 번째 절에서 명사 대체
문법 구조
- `Noun + which + Clause` 표준 패턴
- Subject/Object 둘 다 가능
- Defining Clauses 필수 정보
`Who` vs. `Which` vs. `That`
사물에 맞는 관계대명사 선택 흐름도
그 명사가 사람인가요?
그 명사가 사물, 동물 또는 아이디어인가요?
이 정보가 명사를 식별하는 데 필수적인가요?
관계대명사가 절의 주어 역할을 하나요?
"Which"의 현대적 맥락
온라인 대화
- • 친구와 문자
- • 게임 음성 채팅
- • 온라인 리뷰
일상생활
- • 음식 주문 (앱)
- • 커피숍 대화
- • 문제 설명
학업/전문
- • 대학교 그룹 프로젝트
- • 줌 면접
- • 보고서/프레젠테이션
엔터테인먼트
- • 넷플릭스 자막
- • 영화/쇼 토론
- • 인스타그램/틱톡 캡션
수준별 예문
I have a car which is red.
I have a car which is red.
This is the book which I like.
This is the book which I like.
The dog which is in the garden is mine.
The dog which is in the garden is mine.
I want the cake which has chocolate.
I want the cake which has chocolate.
The phone which I bought yesterday is broken.
The phone which I bought yesterday is broken.
Is this the bus which goes to the airport?
Is this the bus which goes to the airport?
I lost the keys which were on the table.
I lost the keys which were on the table.
The movie which we saw was very funny.
The movie which we saw was very funny.
My computer, which is quite old, is very slow.
My computer, which is quite old, is very slow.
He forgot my birthday, which made me sad.
He forgot my birthday, which made me sad.
The hotel which we stayed in was near the beach.
The hotel which we stayed in was near the beach.
I need a job which allows me to work from home.
I need a job which allows me to work from home.
The document to which you are referring is lost.
The document to which you are referring is lost.
The city, which was founded in 1200, is famous for its art.
The city, which was founded in 1200, is famous for its art.
They offered me a promotion, which I immediately accepted.
They offered me a promotion, which I immediately accepted.
The criteria by which we judge success are changing.
The criteria by which we judge success are changing.
The proposal, the merits of which are debatable, was rejected.
The proposal, the merits of which are debatable, was rejected.
He was late for the meeting, which fact he failed to mention.
He was late for the meeting, which fact he failed to mention.
The system, which had been failing for years, finally collapsed.
The system, which had been failing for years, finally collapsed.
It was a decision from which there was no turning back.
It was a decision from which there was no turning back.
The treaty, the signing of which heralded a new era, was brief.
The treaty, the signing of which heralded a new era, was brief.
She argued that the law was unjust, which view was widely shared.
She argued that the law was unjust, which view was widely shared.
The company went bankrupt, which outcome surprised no one.
The company went bankrupt, which outcome surprised no one.
We reached the summit at noon, by which time the fog had lifted.
We reached the summit at noon, by which time the fog had lifted.
혼동하기 쉬운
Learners often use 'that' after a comma or 'which' without a comma when they shouldn't.
Using 'which' for people or 'who' for objects.
Using 'what' to join two sentences.
자주 하는 실수
The man which is tall.
The man who is tall.
The book it is good.
The book which is good.
I like the cat who is black.
I like the cat which is black.
The car which it is red.
The car which is red.
The movie what I saw.
The movie which I saw.
The pen which I write with it.
The pen which I write with.
The house where I bought.
The house which I bought.
My car, that is old, broke down.
My car, which is old, broke down.
He was late that was annoying.
He was late, which was annoying.
The city which I live is big.
The city which I live in is big.
The company who's profits are high.
The company, the profits of which are high.
문장 패턴
I have a ___ which ___.
The ___ which I ___ is ___.
My ___, which is ___, is ___.
___, which meant that ___.
Real World Usage
I want to return the shoes which I ordered last week.
I am looking for a role which offers growth opportunities.
I lost my phone, which is why I didn't call.
Is this the museum which has the Picasso paintings?
Click the button which is located in the top right corner.
Check out this sunset, which was taken without a filter!
명확하게 "Which" 쓰기
which를 써서 문장을 명확하게 만들어요. 헷갈리지 않게 도와주죠! I need the report which has the latest sales figures.
사람에게는 절대 "Which"를 쓰지 마세요! ⚠️
which는 사람에게 사용하지 않아요. 개인, 그룹, 직업을 나타낼 때는 항상 who나 that을 써야 해요! The student who passed the exam was happy.
"Which"를 생략해도 될 때
which (또는 that)가 관계절의 *목적어*일 때는 가끔 생략할 수 있어요. 예를 들어, The movie (which) I watched...처럼요. 하지만
which가 주어일 때는 절대 생략하면 안 돼요! The book which was written by him is famous.
격식체 vs. 비격식체
which가 오는 것 (the device with which)은 격식 있는 글쓰기에서 정확하지만, 일상 대화에서는 전치사를 문장 끝으로 옮기는 경우가 더 많아요: "That's the car which I went on a trip with."'사물, 동물, 아이디어'를 떠올려 보세요
who를 써야 할지 which를 써야 할지 헷갈릴 때는 이렇게 스스로에게 물어보세요: '이게 사람인가?' 사람이 아니라면, which가 정답일 확률이 높아요. 참 쉽죠? I bought a new phone which has a great camera.
Smart Tips
Use 'which' instead of 'that' to sound more professional and precise.
Use ', which' at the end of your sentence to share your opinion.
Never use 'that' after a comma in a relative clause. It's always 'which'.
Try removing 'which' to see if the sentence sounds more natural in speech.
발음
The 'wh' sound
In most modern English dialects, 'which' is pronounced exactly like 'witch' /wɪtʃ/. Some older or regional dialects (like Scottish) might use a voiceless 'w' /hw/.
Comma Intonation
In non-defining clauses, there is a slight drop in pitch and a brief pause where the commas are.
Non-defining drop
The cake, ↘ which was chocolate, ↗ was eaten.
The information inside the commas is parenthetical (extra).
암기하기
기억법
W-H-I-C-H: Whatever Has Inanimate Characteristics Here.
시각적 연상
Imagine a giant question mark (?) turning into a bridge. The bridge connects a box (the object) to a label (the description). The bridge is made of the letters W-H-I-C-H.
Rhyme
For a person use 'who', for a thing 'which' will do.
Story
A robot named 'Which' only collects objects. He picks up a 'ball which is round' and a 'box which is heavy'. He never picks up people because he doesn't understand 'who' they are.
Word Web
챌린지
Look around your room. Pick 5 objects and describe them using 'which'. (e.g., 'The chair which is near the window is brown.')
문화 노트
American style guides (like APA or Chicago) are very strict about using 'that' for defining clauses and 'which' only for non-defining clauses.
British English is more flexible. It is very common to hear 'which' used in defining clauses where an American would almost always use 'that'.
In academic writing globally, 'which' is preferred for its precision, especially when used with prepositions like 'in which' or 'by which'.
From Old English 'hwilc', which was originally a question word meaning 'of what form'.
대화 시작하기
What is a movie which you have seen many times?
Tell me about a hobby which you started recently.
Describe a city which you would love to visit.
Think of a problem in your town which needs to be fixed.
일기 주제
자주 하는 실수
Test Yourself
I need the book ___ is on the top shelf.
Find and fix the mistake:
The person which called me was very rude.
Choose the correct sentence:
Translate into English: 'Vi la película que ganó el premio.'
Answer starts with: ["I...
Score: /4
연습 문제
8 exercisesThe car ___ I bought is very fast.
Find and fix the mistake:
The man which lives next door is a doctor.
My bike ___ is in the garage is broken.
I have a new phone. It has a great camera.
Paris, that is the capital of France, is beautiful.
A: Why are you upset? B: I lost my wallet, ___.
Select the non-defining clause.
1. The house... 2. He lied... 3. The dog...
Score: /8
Practice Bank
13 exercisesThe laptop ___ I use for work is very fast.
Choose the correct sentence:
Do you know the café ___ has outdoor seating?
Match the subjects with the correct form:
The movie, who was nominated for an Oscar, is streaming now.
Translate into English: 'Ella tiene un perro que siempre duerme en su cama.'
Arrange these words into a sentence:
The concept ___ he explained was quite complex.
I found the keys was under the couch.
Arrange these words into a sentence:
Translate into English: 'El software, sin el cual no podemos operar, requiere una actualización.'
Which sentence demonstrates the most formal use of 'which'?
The painting, you bought, is beautiful.
Score: /13
자주 묻는 질문 (8)
No, 'which' is strictly for things, animals, and ideas. For people, always use `who` or `whom`.
Use a comma if the information is 'extra' (non-defining). If the information is essential to identify the object, don't use a comma.
In American English, `that` is preferred for essential information. In British English, both are fine. However, only `which` can be used for extra information after a comma.
Yes, but only if it is the object of the clause (e.g., 'The book (which) I bought'). If it is the subject (e.g., 'The book which is on the table'), you must keep it.
It's when `which` refers to the whole previous sentence, not just one word. Example: 'He won, which surprised us.'
Yes, 'which' is the standard pronoun for animals. However, if the animal is a pet with a name, many people use `who`.
It is slightly more formal than `that` in defining clauses, but it is neutral in most other contexts.
It is a formal way to show possession for things. Example: 'The car, the door of which was open...' (Instead of 'whose door').
Scaffolded Practice
1
2
3
4
Mastery Progress
Needs Practice
Improving
Strong
Mastered
In Other Languages
que / el cual
English distinguishes between 'who' (people) and 'which' (things), whereas Spanish often uses 'que' for both.
qui / que / lequel
French relative pronouns change based on grammatical function (subject/object) rather than person/thing.
der / die / das / welcher
German relative pronouns have gender (masculine/feminine/neuter), while English 'which' is gender-neutral.
Attributive form
Japanese uses word order (modifier before noun) instead of a connecting word like 'which'.
al-ladhi (الذي)
English 'which' is much simpler as it doesn't change for number or gender.
de (的)
The structure is reversed: [Description] + de + [Noun].
Learning Path
Prerequisites
Learn These First
Continue With
관련 동영상
The Land Your State Doesn't Control
The Biggest Eruptions That Changed Earth Forever
You Are Not Where You Think You Are
[관계대명사 PART 1] 두 문장 하나로 합치기 / 관계대명사가 왜 필요해요? (who, which, that)
라이브 아카데미
[관계대명사 PART 2] most of which / all of whom 등 (실전에서 이렇게 써요!)
라이브 아카데미
관계대명사, 언제 which를 쓰고 언제 that을 쓸까? | 에스텔잉글리쉬
에스텔잉글리쉬
Related Grammar Rules
관계절: 제한적 용법 vs 비제한적 용법의 의미 차이
Overview 인스타그램 피드를 넘겨보고 있다고 상상해 보세요. 고양이 두 마리를 키우는 친구의 게시물이 보입니다. 한 마리는 하...
관계부사: 장소를 나타내는 'Where'
Overview 친구에게 정말 멋진 피자집에 대해 말해주려다가 문장 중간에 막힌 적 있나요? 있잖아요, 거기. 도우 끝에 꿀을 발라주...
격식 관계절 (in which, to whom)
### Overview 영어를 모국어로 사용하는 환경에서 전문적인 수준의 의사소통을 지향하는 학습자에게 있어, '전치사 + 관계대명사...
문장 줄이기: 축약된 관계절
### Overview 영어를 모국어처럼 구사하고 싶은 B2 레벨의 학습자라면, 문장을 더 간결하고 세련되게 만드는 기술인 '축약된 관...
Whose: 소유를 나타내기
### Overview 영어에서 `whose`는 **소유격 관계대명사(possessive relative pronoun)**로 불리며, 문장 내에서 두 가지 정보를...