Reporting What People Said (Tense Backshift)
Grammar Rule in 30 Seconds
When reporting past speech, move the verb one step into the past to show the time gap.
- Move present tenses to past tenses: 'I am' becomes 'He said he was'.
- Change pronouns to match the new speaker: 'I like' becomes 'She said she liked'.
- Shift time words: 'today' becomes 'that day' and 'here' becomes 'there'.
Overview
Tell people what a friend said. Use words like "said."
Move the time of the words back.
This makes your story clear. People know when things happened.
"She was hungry" means she felt it before. This is good.
How This Grammar Works
am busy," their present simple statement is true at the moment of their speaking. When you report this later, saying, "He said...", that present simple state for him is now in your past.Formation Pattern
Present Simple | Past Simple | "I like coffee." | She said she liked coffee. |
Present Perfect | Past Perfect | "I have finished the report." | They confirmed they had finished the report. |
Past Simple | Past Perfect | "I bought a new car." | He told me he had bought a new car. |
Past Perfect | Past Perfect | "I had already eaten." | He explained he had already eaten. |
will (future) | would | "I will call you tomorrow." | He promised he would call me the next day. |
can | could | "I can help you." | She said she could help me. |
may | might | "It may rain later." | They thought it might rain later. |
must (obligation) | had to | "I must leave now." | He stated he had to leave then. |
must (deduction) | must (or had to) | "It must be true." | She said it must be true. (or it had to be true) |
shall (future/suggestion) | would/should | "I shall be there." / "Shall I open?" | He said he would be there. / He asked if he should open.|
When To Use It
- Establishing Temporal Distance:
Backshiftclearly signals that the reported event or state occurred in a past time frame relative to your current act of speaking. It creates a cohesive narrative, preventing confusion about when the original statement was made versus when its content was true. For example, if a friend told you last week, "Iam studyingfor my exams," and you tell another friend today, "She saidshe was studyingfor her exams," the backshift correctly places her studying in the past relative to your current conversation. - Maintaining Consistency in Narrative: In stories, summaries, or formal reports,
backshifthelps maintain a consistent past perspective. If you are recounting a series of events that happened in the past, and you introduce someone's speech within that narrative,backshiftingtheir words integrates them seamlessly into the overall past timeline. This is particularly important in academic writing or news reporting where precision is paramount. - Reflecting a Change in Circumstance:
Backshiftis especially useful when the content of the reported speech may no longer be true or relevant at the moment of reporting. By shifting the tense, you imply that the original statement was accurate at that time, without committing to its present truth. For example, if someone said, "Iam feelingunwell," reporting it as "He saidhe was feelingunwell" acknowledges his past state without asserting he is still unwell now.
- Relaying Information to Others: After a meeting, you might tell a colleague, "The manager announced
the project deadline had been extendedby a week." (Original: "The project deadlinehas been extended.") ThePresent PerfectbecomesPast Perfectbecause the announcement (and extension) occurred prior to your current conversation. - Recounting Past Conversations: "My grandmother always used to say
she had seenmany changes in her lifetime." (Original: "Ihave seenmany changes...") Here, thePresent Perfectin direct speech becomesPast Perfectin reported speech, appropriately framing the past statement within a past narrative. - Providing Updates or Explanations: If you missed a class and asked a classmate for notes, you might explain, "My friend told me
the professor had givenan extra assignment." (Original: "The professorgavean extra assignment.") ThePast Simplegavetransforms toPast Perfecthad givenbecause the giving of the assignment happened before your friend's telling.
Common Mistakes
- Failing to Backshift When Necessary: This is the most frequent error. If your
reporting verbis in the past, but you leave the verb in thereported clausein its original (present) tense, it can create ambiguity or imply that the original statement is still true or relevant in the present moment, even if it is not. For example, if someone said last week, "Iam goingon holiday," and you report "She said sheis goingon holiday," it incorrectly suggests she is still actively planning or on her way right now. The correct backshift would be "She saidshe was goingon holiday." - Over-Backshifting (Applying Backshift When Not Required): Conversely, some learners backshift even when it's grammatically unnecessary or incorrect. This typically occurs in two main situations:
- Present Reporting Verb: Using a present
reporting verb(e.g.,says,tells) and then backshifting. "Hesayshewashungry" is incorrect if he is still hungry, or ifsaysrefers to a current statement. It should be "Hesaysheishungry." - General Truths/Still True Statements: Backshifting
general truthsor statements that arestill undeniably true. While sometimes acceptable forstill truestatements (as mentioned in exceptions), it's redundant and can sound unnatural for universal facts. "The scientist explainedgravity wasa fundamental force" is incorrect; it should be "gravity isa fundamental force." - Neglecting Adverbial Changes: When backshifting tenses, you must also often adjust
time and place adverbialsto maintain logical consistency. Failing to do so can lead to confusion. For example, if someone says, "Iwill seeyoutomorrow," and you report it as "He said hewould seemetomorrow," it's illogical becausetomorrowfrom the original speaker's perspective is no longertomorrowfrom your reporting perspective. The correct change istomorrowtothe next dayorthe following day. Similarly,herebecomesthere,nowbecomesthen,todaybecomesthat day,yesterdaybecomesthe day before, andlast weekbecomesthe week beforeorthe previous week. - Incorrect Modal Backshift: Attempting to backshift modals that do not change (e.g.,
could,should,would,might). For instance, transforming "She said, 'Ishould study'" into "She saidshe had had to study" is incorrect. The correct reported form is "She saidshe should study." These modals already convey a nuance that doesn't typically require further temporal distancing in reported speech. - Misusing
sayvs.tell: While a separate rule, this often goes hand-in-hand with reported speech errors. Remember: yousay somethingorsay that something. Youtell someone somethingortell someone that something. An indirect object is required withtell. Incorrect: "Hetold thathe was busy." Correct: "Hetold me thathe was busy." or "Hesaid thathe was busy." - Incorrect Word Order in Reported Questions: When reporting a question, it transforms into a statement, meaning you lose the inverted subject-verb order of a direct question. Incorrect: "She asked
where did I go." Correct: "She askedwhere I had gone." The tense also backshifts.
Real Conversations
Tense backshift is not just a textbook rule; it is an integral part of how native speakers communicate in various real-world contexts, from informal chats to formal documents. Observing its application in modern usage can deepen your understanding:
- Social Media & Texting (Informal): Even in quick, informal digital communication, backshift is common, especially when relaying gossip or updates from earlier conversations. Imagine texting a friend: "OMG, Liam said he was going to quit! I’m shook!" (Original: "I am going to quit!"). Or, "My sister DM’d she had finished the whole series last night." (Original: "I have finished the whole series.") While that is often omitted for brevity, the tense shift remains.
- Work & Academic Settings (Formal/Semi-Formal): In professional emails, meeting summaries, or academic discussions, precise backshift demonstrates clarity and professionalism. You might write: "The client confirmed they had received the updated proposal on Monday." (Original: "We received the updated proposal."). Or in a presentation: "Dr. Evans stated his research indicated a significant correlation." (Original: "My research indicates...") This usage ensures the timeline of information is unambiguous for a wider audience.
- News Reporting & Interviews: Journalists frequently use reported speech to attribute information, and backshift is standard. A news report might state: "The spokesperson announced the new policy would take effect next month." (Original: "The new policy will take effect..."). In an interview summary: "The CEO clarified the company had exceeded its revenue targets." (Original: "The company has exceeded its revenue targets.") This maintains objective reporting and contextualises statements.
- Everyday Conversations: In daily interactions, backshift naturally structures your recounting of events. "My mum called and said she would be late for dinner." (Original: "I will be late.") Or: "I told the mechanic I had heard a strange noise from the engine." (Original: "I heard a strange noise.") The choice to backshift often happens subconsciously for native speakers, signifying a natural grasp of temporal relations in language.
Quick FAQ
had already finished the work'" becomes "She said she had already finished the work."says he is coming," not "He says he was coming."Tense Backshift Mapping
| Direct Speech Tense | Reported Speech Tense | Direct Example | Reported Example |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Present Simple
|
Past Simple
|
I work
|
He said he worked
|
|
Present Continuous
|
Past Continuous
|
I am working
|
He said he was working
|
|
Past Simple
|
Past Perfect
|
I worked
|
He said he had worked
|
|
Present Perfect
|
Past Perfect
|
I have worked
|
He said he had worked
|
|
Will
|
Would
|
I will work
|
He said he would work
|
|
Can
|
Could
|
I can work
|
He said he could work
|
|
Am/Is/Are going to
|
Was/Were going to
|
I am going to work
|
He said he was going to work
|
Common Contractions in Reported Speech
| Full Form | Contraction | Example |
|---|---|---|
|
He said he had
|
He said he'd
|
He said he'd finished.
|
|
She said she would
|
She said she'd
|
She said she'd help.
|
|
They said they were
|
They said they're (rare)
|
Usually kept as 'they were'.
|
Meanings
Reported speech is used to communicate what someone else said without using their exact words. We usually change the tense of the original verb to a past form because the speaking event happened in the past.
Reporting Statements
Relaying factual information or opinions shared by others using reporting verbs like 'say' or 'tell'.
“She said that she had already finished the report.”
“They told us they were planning a surprise party.”
Reporting Questions
Relaying questions using 'ask', 'wonder', or 'want to know', often using 'if' or 'whether' for yes/no questions.
“He asked if I knew the way to the station.”
“She wondered where I had bought my shoes.”
Reporting Commands and Requests
Using an infinitive structure (to + verb) to report what someone told or asked someone to do.
“The doctor told me to drink more water.”
“She asked him not to smoke in the house.”
Reference Table
| Form | Structure | Example |
|---|---|---|
|
Affirmative Statement
|
Subject + said + (that) + Subject + Past Verb
|
He said he was tired.
|
|
Negative Statement
|
Subject + said + (that) + Subject + didn't/hadn't + Verb
|
She said she hadn't seen him.
|
|
Yes/No Question
|
Subject + asked + if/whether + Subject + Past Verb
|
They asked if I was coming.
|
|
Wh- Question
|
Subject + asked + Wh-word + Subject + Past Verb
|
He asked where I lived.
|
|
Command
|
Subject + told + Object + to + Infinitive
|
The boss told me to wait.
|
|
Negative Command
|
Subject + told + Object + not to + Infinitive
|
She told him not to go.
|
Formality Spectrum
The employee stated that the assignment had been completed. (Workplace)
He said that he had finished the work. (Workplace)
He said he was done. (Workplace)
He was like, 'I'm finished.' (Workplace)
The Reporting Shift
Tense
- Backshift Move one step to the past
Pronouns
- Perspective I -> He/She
Time/Place
- Deictic Shift Here -> There
Direct vs. Indirect
How to Report a Sentence
Is it a question?
Is the reporting verb in the past?
Examples by Level
He said, 'I am a student.'
She said, 'I like apples.'
They said, 'We are cold.'
I said, 'I am hungry.'
He said he liked the movie.
She told me she was busy.
They said they lived in London.
He asked if I wanted coffee.
She said she had already seen that film.
He asked where I had been the day before.
They told us they would arrive at 8 PM.
The boss asked if I could finish the report.
He admitted that he had made a mistake.
She suggested going to the park.
It was reported that the company was closing.
He asked what I would have done in his position.
The witness alleged that the suspect had been fleeing the scene.
She questioned whether the results were truly representative.
He conceded that the project had been more difficult than anticipated.
The article contended that the policy was fundamentally flawed.
The philosopher postulated that existence preceded essence.
He recounted how he had been wandering the streets for hours.
The diplomat underscored that a resolution must be reached immediately.
She lamented that the golden age of cinema had long since passed.
Easily Confused
Learners often use 'say' with a person or 'tell' without one.
Learners keep the question word order (Verb-Subject) instead of switching to statement order (Subject-Verb).
Learners aren't sure if they *must* backshift if the fact is still true.
Common Mistakes
He said I am happy.
He said he was happy.
She said me she is tired.
She told me she was tired.
He said that he like pizza.
He said that he liked pizza.
They said they are here.
They said they were there.
He asked me where was the bank.
He asked me where the bank was.
She asked if I have seen the movie.
She asked if I had seen the movie.
He told to me to go.
He told me to go.
He said he will come tomorrow.
He said he would come the next day.
She asked me what did I do.
She asked me what I had done.
He said he had went there.
He said he had gone there.
He suggested me to go.
He suggested that I should go / He suggested going.
Sentence Patterns
He said that he ___ (past verb) ___.
She asked me if I ___ (past verb) ___.
They told us not to ___ (verb) ___.
It is widely believed that ___ (subject + verb) ___.
Real World Usage
He said the deadline had been moved to Friday.
She said she's gonna be late.
The police reported that the road was closed.
Did you hear? He said he was quitting!
Smith (2020) argued that the data was inconclusive.
The witness claimed she had never seen the man before.
The 'That' Trick
Question Order
Say vs Tell
Reporting Verbs
Smart Tips
Immediately think: 'No do/does/did' and 'Switch the order'.
Change 'will' to 'would' every single time.
Check if there is a person (me, you, her) after the verb. Person = Tell. No person = Say.
Shift the time! 'Yesterday' -> 'the day before', 'Tomorrow' -> 'the next day'.
Pronunciation
The 'that' reduction
In reported speech, the word 'that' is often unstressed and pronounced as a schwa /ðət/.
Intonation in reported questions
Unlike direct questions, reported questions have a falling intonation at the end because they are statements.
Reporting Statement
She said she was ↘ hungry.
Conveys a completed piece of information.
Memorize It
Mnemonic
The 'Backstep' Rule: If the reporting verb is in the past, the message takes a step back in time.
Visual Association
Imagine a timeline. When you report someone's words, you physically pick up the verb and move it one square to the left (the past).
Rhyme
When 'said' is the word you use, the present tense you're bound to lose.
Story
A spy overhears a secret: 'I am meeting the contact tomorrow.' He runs to his boss and reports: 'He said he was meeting the contact the next day.' The spy must change the time and tense so the boss doesn't go to the wrong place at the wrong time.
Word Web
Challenge
Look at your last 3 text messages. Rewrite them as if you were telling a friend what those people said using 'He/She said that...'.
Cultural Notes
In the UK, 'shall' in direct speech ('Shall we go?') often shifts to 'should' in reported speech ('He asked if we should go').
Americans frequently use 'like' as a reporting verb in very informal speech ('He was like, "No way!"'). This is common among younger generations.
Journalists use 'allegedly' or reporting verbs like 'claimed' to avoid legal trouble when reporting something that isn't proven yet.
Reported speech structures have existed since Old English, though the strict 'backshift' rules became more formalized as the English tense system became more complex during the Middle English period.
Conversation Starters
What did your boss or teacher tell you to do yesterday?
Tell me about a secret someone told you recently (without names!).
What is the most interesting thing you heard on the news today?
If you could report a conversation between two famous people, who would they be?
Journal Prompts
Common Mistakes
Test Yourself
Direct: 'I am living in London.'
Direct: 'I have lost my keys.' -> She said she ___ her keys.
Find and fix the mistake:
He asked me where did I live.
Direct: 'I will call you tomorrow.'
Match each item on the left with its pair on the right:
She told that she was coming.
A: 'Are you coming?' B: 'What did he ask?' C: 'He asked ___.'
Select the correct one.
Score: /8
Practice Exercises
8 exercisesDirect: 'I am living in London.'
Direct: 'I have lost my keys.' -> She said she ___ her keys.
Find and fix the mistake:
He asked me where did I live.
Direct: 'I will call you tomorrow.'
1. 'I can swim' 2. 'I am swimming' 3. 'I swam'
She told that she was coming.
A: 'Are you coming?' B: 'What did he ask?' C: 'He asked ___.'
Select the correct one.
Score: /8
Practice Bank
13 exercisesThey explained that they ___ to Paris last year.
He swore he `will` keep my secret.
Choose the correct sentence:
Translate into English: 'Él preguntó dónde vivía yo.'
Arrange these words into a sentence:
Match the tenses:
The coach emphasized that they ___ to practice harder.
She informed me that her brother `can` speak French.
Choose the correct sentence:
Translate into English: 'Ella dijo: "Puedo ayudarte".'
Arrange these words into a sentence:
Match the modals:
I heard she ___ sick last week.
Score: /13
FAQ (8)
Not always. If the statement is still true (e.g., 'The capital of France is Paris'), you can keep it in the present. However, backshifting is always correct and safer in exams.
'Must' usually changes to 'had to' in reported speech. For example, 'I must go' becomes 'He said he had to go'.
Only if you use 'to'. You can say 'He said to me that...', but it is much more common to say 'He told me that...'.
Use the question word, then the subject, then the verb. 'Where is he?' becomes 'She asked where he was'.
'This' usually becomes 'that', and 'these' becomes 'those'. For example, 'I like this book' becomes 'He said he liked that book'.
No, it is optional. 'He said he was tired' and 'He said that he was tired' are both correct, but the version without 'that' is more common in speaking.
If the reporting verb is in the present, you do NOT backshift. 'He says he is hungry' stays in the present.
Use 'tell' + person + 'to' + verb. 'Sit down!' becomes 'He told me to sit down'.
Scaffolded Practice
1
2
3
4
Mastery Progress
Needs Practice
Improving
Strong
Mastered
In Other Languages
Estilo indirecto
Spanish often uses the subjunctive mood for reported commands, whereas English uses the infinitive.
Le discours indirect
French tense harmony is often stricter in formal writing than English.
Indirekte Rede (Konjunktiv I)
English uses past tenses for reporting; German uses a special verb form.
引用 (In'yō)
No tense changes occur in Japanese reported speech.
الكلام المنقول (al-kalam al-manqul)
Tense consistency is based more on the time of the event than a grammatical rule.
间接引语 (Jiànjiē yǐnyǔ)
Verbs never change form in Chinese reported speech.
Learning Path
Prerequisites
Continue With
Reported Speech: Say vs. Tell
Overview Mastering the distinction between `say` and `tell` in reported speech is fundamental for advanced English commu...
Reported Speech: Time and Place Changes
Overview When you recount what someone else has said, you invariably shift the perspective from the original speaker to...
Reported Yes/No Questions: 'Asked if...'
Overview The ability to accurately report what someone else has asked is a cornerstone of effective communication in Eng...
Reported Questions: Using Wh- Words (what, where, why)
Overview Reporting questions, particularly those beginning with Wh- words like `what`, `where`, and `why`, allows you to...
Reported Commands: Telling someone what to do
Overview Reported commands allow you to convey an instruction, request, or order given by someone else without quoting t...
Reported Questions with Question Words (Who, What, Why)
Overview Mastering reported questions with question words (`who`, `what`, `why`, `where`, `when`, `how`, `which`, `whose...
Reported Yes/No Questions (If/Whether)
Overview As an advanced English learner operating at the C1 CEFR level, you routinely navigate intricate syntactic struc...
Reported Commands and Requests: Telling others what to do
Overview Reported commands and requests are a crucial component of advanced English communication, enabling speakers and...
Reported Speech with Modals & Passive Reporting (C1)
Overview Mastering reported speech with modals and passive reporting structures marks a significant step towards C1-leve...
Related Videos
All Penguins Are From Australia
Mississippi Chicken Chili | Food Wishes
What is kink?: Sex Ed #15
REPORTED SPEECH in English - Indirect Speech | Reported Speech | Direct Speech (+ Free PDF & Quiz)
English with Lucy
Learn English Grammar: Reported Speech
Learn English with Rebecca · engVid
Learn English Grammar: DIRECT & INDIRECT SPEECH (REPORTED SPEECH)
Learn English with Gill · engVid
Related Grammar Rules
Passive Voice for Objectivity: 'It is said that...'
Overview English grammar provides specific structures to report information without identifying the source, or to emphas...
Reported Speech with Modals & Passive Reporting (C1)
Overview Mastering reported speech with modals and passive reporting structures marks a significant step towards C1-leve...
Reporting Verbs: Who Said What?
Overview Reporting verbs are essential linguistic tools that enable you to relay information or summarise statements, qu...
When to Use Passive Voice (Reporting News & Rumors)
Overview The passive voice in English serves various crucial communicative functions, particularly when the agent of an...
Passive Reporting Structures (He is said to be...)
Overview Passive reporting structures, epitomized by phrases such as `He is said to be...`, serve as sophisticated tools...