A1 Present Tense 14 min read Easy

The Verb ESTAR: Temporary 'To Be' (estou, está)

Use estar for temporary states and locations; use ser for permanent identity and characteristics.

Grammar Rule in 30 Seconds

Use 'estar' for temporary states, locations, and feelings; remember it's the 'not permanent' version of 'to be'.

  • Use 'estar' for physical locations: 'Eu estou em casa' (I am at home).
  • Use 'estar' for temporary moods or health: 'Ela está feliz' (She is happy).
  • Use 'estar' for ongoing actions (with -ndo): 'Nós estamos comendo' (We are eating).
Subject + Estar (conjugated) + State/Location

Overview

The Portuguese verb estar translates directly to 'to be' in English, but its usage is fundamentally distinct from the verb ser, which also means 'to be'. While ser describes inherent, permanent, or defining qualities, estar focuses on temporary states, conditions, locations, and actions in progress. It captures how something is at a particular moment, rather than what it is inherently.

Understanding this core distinction is paramount for A1 learners, as misusing ser and estar can lead to significant changes in meaning. For instance, Ele é cansado (He is a tiring/boring person) implies a permanent trait, whereas Ele está cansado (He is tired right now) describes a temporary physical state. This dual system for 'to be' allows Portuguese to express nuances unavailable in English's single verb structure.

How This Grammar Works

Estar is an irregular verb, meaning its conjugations do not follow the predictable patterns of regular -ar verbs. Its forms must be memorized. Despite its irregularity, estar is one of the most frequently used verbs in Portuguese, essential for conveying dynamic aspects of reality.
It primarily functions in three contexts: indicating location, describing temporary states or conditions (physical, emotional, health, or temporary characteristics), and forming progressive tenses (actions happening at the moment of speaking). The fundamental linguistic principle behind estar is its emphasis on temporality and changeability. If a characteristic, feeling, or location is subject to change, estar is the appropriate choice.
For example, Eu estou feliz (I am happy now, but this state can change), while Eu sou feliz (I am a happy person, implying a consistent disposition). Portuguese frequently omits subject pronouns (e.g., Eu estou becomes Estou), as the verb conjugation itself indicates the subject, a feature common in Romance languages. This makes the language more concise in everyday speech.

Formation Pattern

1
Forming sentences with estar follows a straightforward pattern: Subject + Conjugated estar + Complement. The complement can be an adjective describing a state, a prepositional phrase indicating location, or a gerund (-ndo form) for progressive actions. The primary challenge for learners lies in correctly conjugating estar according to the subject and selecting the appropriate complement, ensuring agreement where necessary (e.g., adjective gender and number). For example, to express 'I am busy,' you combine the subject Eu (I), the estar conjugation estou (am), and the adjective ocupado/ocupada (busy), resulting in Eu estou ocupado (for a male speaker) or Eu estou ocupada (for a female speaker). When expressing location, you typically use estar followed by a preposition like em (in/at), na (in/at the feminine), no (in/at the masculine), or perto de (near). For instance, Nós estamos em casa (We are at home) or Eles estão na universidade (They are at the university).

Conjugation Table

Subject Pronoun Conjugation (BP/EP) Example (BP) Translation
:-------------- :------------------ :-------------------------------- :--------------------------
Eu (I) estou Eu estou bem. I am well.
Tu (You, sing. informal) estás (EP primary) Tu estás em Portugal. You are in Portugal.
Você (You, sing. formal/BP informal) está Você está feliz. You are happy.
Ele/Ela (He/She) está Ele está no trabalho. He is at work.
Nós (We) estamos Nós estamos com fome. We are hungry.
Vós (You, pl. informal/archaic) estais (EP, highly formal/archaic) Vós estais cansados. You all are tired.
Vocês (You, pl. formal/BP informal) estão Vocês estão prontos. You all are ready.
Eles/Elas (They) estão Eles estão estudando. They are studying.

When To Use It

Estar is used in several key situations, all revolving around the concept of temporality, state, or location.
  • Location (Position of People or Objects): Whether permanent or temporary, the position of entities requires estar. This is a strict rule: you are in a place, not the place itself. Even if your home is a permanent fixture, your presence there is a temporary state. Onde você está? (Where are you?) Eu estou em casa. (I am at home.) O livro está na mesa. (The book is on the table.)
  • Temporary States, Conditions, and Feelings: This category is broad, encompassing physical, emotional, and health states. These are typically transient and subject to change. For example, happiness, sadness, illness, tiredness, and hunger are all temporary states. Estou feliz hoje. (I am happy today.) Ela está doente. (She is sick.) Eles estão cansados da viagem. (They are tired from the trip.) You use estar com to express certain physical states like hunger (com fome), thirst (com sede), cold (com frio), or heat (com calor). Estou com muita sede. (I am very thirsty.)
  • Temporary Qualities or Characteristics: When a characteristic is not inherent but represents a temporary aspect or a deviation from the norm, estar is used. For instance, someone can be intelligent (ser inteligente) as a permanent trait, but they can be acting stupid (estar estúpido) at a particular moment. A comida está fria. (The food is cold now, implying it should be hot.) Ele está muito chato hoje. (He is being very annoying today, implying this isn't his usual disposition.) This use often implies a comparison to a usual state or a change.
  • Progressive Tenses (Actions in Progress): To describe an action happening at the moment of speaking, Portuguese uses estar followed by a gerund (-ndo ending for most verbs, like falando - speaking, comendo - eating, dormindo - sleeping). This is equivalent to the English 'to be + -ing'. Estou aprendendo português. (I am learning Portuguese.) Elas estão trabalhando agora. (They are working now.) In European Portuguese, the progressive is often formed with estar a + infinitive, as in Estou a aprender português., though estar + gerund is also understood and used.
  • Weather Expressions: Estar is frequently used with adjectives or gerunds to describe the weather, which is inherently temporary. Está chovendo. (It is raining.) Está calor. (It is hot.) Está ensolarado. (It is sunny.)

When Not To Use It

Avoiding estar in specific contexts is as crucial as knowing when to use it, primarily to prevent confusion with ser.
  • Permanent Characteristics and Identity (Use ser): Do not use estar for nationality, profession, permanent physical traits, inherent qualities, or identity. Eu sou brasileiro. (I am Brazilian.) Ele é médico. (He is a doctor.) A casa é grande. (The house is big – referring to its inherent size.) Using estar in these contexts would imply a temporary or feigned identity, which can be unintentionally humorous or offensive. For example, Eu estou médico suggests 'I am acting as a doctor' or 'I am a temporary doctor.'
  • Possession (Use ter or ser de): Estar is never used to express possession. Instead, use ter (to have) or ser de (to be of/belong to). Eu tenho um carro. (I have a car.) O livro é do Pedro. (The book belongs to Pedro.)
  • Origin (Use ser de): To state where someone or something comes from, use ser de. Eu sou de Lisboa. (I am from Lisbon.) O vinho é de Portugal. (The wine is from Portugal.)
  • Time (Use ser): When telling time or dating events, ser is used. Que horas são? São dez horas. (What time is it? It's ten o'clock.) Hoje é terça-feira. (Today is Tuesday.)

Common Mistakes

Learners frequently make specific errors when distinguishing ser and estar, primarily due to the single 'to be' verb in English.
  • Ser for Location: The most common and often glaring mistake is using ser to indicate location. You can never ser a place. You estar in or at a place. For example, Eu sou em casa is incorrect; it should be Eu estou em casa. This error is so prevalent that it immediately identifies a non-native speaker. Remember: Ser defines what you are; estar defines where you are or how you are.
  • Gender and Number Agreement with Adjectives: When estar is followed by an adjective, the adjective must agree in gender (masculine/feminine) and number (singular/plural) with the subject. Failing to do so is a common oversight. For example, if a female speaker says Estou cansado, it is incorrect; it should be Estou cansada. For multiple people, Nós estamos feliz is wrong; it should be Nós estamos felizes.
  • Confusing Permanent and Temporary Qualities: Misinterpreting whether a characteristic is temporary or permanent leads to incorrect verb choice. Ela é linda (She is beautiful – a defining quality) vs. Ela está linda (She looks beautiful today – perhaps dressed up, or feeling good). The implication of estar is that this beauty is an observable state at a given moment, whereas ser refers to inherent beauty. Similarly, Ele é mau (He is a bad person) versus Ele está mau (He is in a bad mood/feeling unwell). The context dictates the meaning entirely.
  • Overuse of Informal : While and (shortened forms of estou and está) are common in informal Brazilian Portuguese speech and texting, using them in formal contexts (e.g., job interviews, academic presentations) can sound unprofessional or overly casual. Learners should be mindful of the register. Stick to the full conjugations estou, está, etc., in formal situations.

Memory Trick

To easily recall when to use estar, remember the acronym P.L.A.C.E.:

- Position (Location): Estou em casa.

- Location: A faculdade está no centro.

- Action (Progressive): Estamos estudando.

- Condition (Temporary state/feeling): Ela está feliz.

- Emotion (Feeling): Você está triste?

Alternatively, consider the ST in eSTar for STate and Temporary. If the description is a STate that is Temporary, use estar. For inherent qualities or identity, the lack of ST in ser reminds you it's for something more permanent.

Real Conversations

Understanding estar in natural dialogue helps solidify its usage. Here are examples reflecting modern Portuguese communication:

S

Scenario 1

Checking on a friend's well-being (informal BP)
F

Friend A

Oi! Tudo bem? Como você está? (Hi! All good? How are you?)
F

Friend B

Estou bem, só um pouco cansado do trabalho. E você, está tudo certo? (I'm good, just a bit tired from work. And you, is everything okay?)
S

Scenario 2

Describing a current situation (formal EP)
C

Colleague

Onde está a Maria? Precisamos dela na reunião. (Where is Maria? We need her in the meeting.)
M

Manager

Ela está a almoçar neste momento. Deve estar de volta em 15 minutos. (She is having lunch at the moment. She should be back in 15 minutes.)
S

Scenario 3

Texting about plans (informal BP with )
F

Friend A

Tá pronto pra festa? Tô chegando! (Are you ready for the party? I'm arriving!)
F

Friend B

Quase! Tô me arrumando ainda. Te vejo lá! (Almost! I'm still getting ready. See you there!)

These examples showcase estar for current states (cansado), location (a almoçar, chegando), and temporary conditions (pronto). The usage illustrates colloquial speech.

Contrast With Similar Patterns

The most significant contrast for estar is with ser. However, ficar also presents some overlap.
  • Ser vs. Estar (The Core Distinction): This is the cornerstone of Portuguese 'to be' verbs. Ser is for permanent, intrinsic, defining qualities, identity, origin, and characteristics that are fundamental to something. Estar is for temporary, changeable states, conditions, locations, and actions in progress. The meaning of an adjective can drastically change depending on which verb precedes it.
  • A maçã é verde. (The apple is green – it's an unripe apple, its inherent state of being green is permanent for this specific type/stage of apple.)
  • A maçã está verde. (The apple is green – it's green now, implying it's not ripe yet, a temporary condition before it turns red, or perhaps it's moldy and green.)
  • João é bonito. (João is handsome – he is an inherently handsome person.)
  • João está bonito. (João looks handsome – he looks handsome right now, perhaps because he dressed up, got a haircut, or is in a good mood.)
  • A sopa é boa. (The soup is good – refers to its inherent quality, recipe, or general deliciousness.)
  • A sopa está boa. (The soup is good now – refers to its current taste, temperature, or condition.)
  • Estar vs. Ficar: While estar describes a current state, ficar (to stay, to become) often implies a change to a state or remaining in a place. Ficar can sometimes replace estar for location, particularly when emphasizing remaining somewhere, but estar is the neutral default. For states, ficar suggests 'to become' or 'to get'.
  • Estou feliz. (I am happy.)
  • Fico feliz quando te vejo. (I become/get happy when I see you – emphasizes the change to the state of happiness.)
  • Fiquei em casa. (I stayed at home.) vs. Estou em casa. (I am at home.)
For beginners, mastering estar for simple states and locations is more crucial before delving into the nuances of ficar.

Progressive Practice

1

Consistent practice is key to internalizing the correct use of estar. Start with foundational exercises and gradually increase complexity.

2

- Self-Description: Describe your current state and location throughout the day. Agora, estou na sala de aula. Estou atento e um pouco cansado. (Now, I am in the classroom. I am attentive and a little tired.)

3

- Observing Your Surroundings: Describe the temporary states or locations of objects and people around you. O café está quente. Minha colega está concentrada. (The coffee is hot. My colleague is concentrated.)

4

- Expressing Actions in Progress: Comment on activities you or others are doing. Estou escrevendo este artigo. Minha família está assistindo TV. (I am writing this article. My family is watching TV.)

5

- Asking and Answering 'How are you?' questions: Engage in simple dialogues. Como você está? Estou ótimo/a, obrigado/a. (How are you? I'm great, thank you.)

6

- Weather Commentary: Describe the weather conditions daily. Hoje, está nublado e está frio. (Today, it is cloudy and it is cold.)

Quick FAQ

Q: Can estar be used with muito (very)?

Yes, absolutely. Estou muito feliz. (I am very happy.) Ele está muito doente. (He is very sick.) This emphasizes the intensity of the temporary state.

Q: What's the difference between estou em casa and sou de casa?

Estou em casa means 'I am at home' (my current location). Sou de casa is an idiomatic expression meaning 'I am one of the family' or 'I am very familiar with the place/situation,' implying a permanent belonging or comfort level.

Q: How do I say 'I am getting better/worse'?

You would typically use estar with melhor (better) or pior (worse). For example, Estou melhor, obrigado. (I am better, thank you.) or Ele está piorando. (He is getting worse – using the progressive tense for a continuous change in state).

Q: Does estar ever imply a permanent state in specific idioms?

While estar generally implies temporality, a few idiomatic expressions might seem to contradict this, but they still relate to a state or condition. For instance, estar de luto (to be in mourning) refers to a state, even if it's prolonged. However, these are exceptions and don't negate the core rule for beginners.

Q: Why is estar com fome used instead of estar fome?

Portuguese often uses estar com (to be with) for certain physical sensations like hunger, thirst, cold, and heat. It's an established grammatical pattern to express 'to feel hungry' or 'to be hungry'. Estou com fome literally means 'I am with hunger,' a fixed expression that learners must memorize.

Conjugation of Estar (Present)

Pronoun Conjugation
Eu
estou
Você/Ele/Ela
está
Nós
estamos
Vocês/Eles/Elas
estão

Meanings

The verb 'estar' is used to describe temporary conditions, locations, and feelings that are subject to change.

1

Location

Where someone or something is currently located.

“Onde você está?”

“O livro está na mesa.”

2

Temporary State

A mood, health condition, or physical state.

“Estou doente.”

“A sopa está quente.”

3

Ongoing Action

Used as an auxiliary verb for the present continuous.

“Estou estudando.”

“Ela está trabalhando.”

Reference Table

Reference table for The Verb ESTAR: Temporary 'To Be' (estou, está)
Form Structure Example
Affirmative
Subject + Estar + Adjective
Eu estou feliz.
Negative
Subject + Não + Estar + Adjective
Eu não estou feliz.
Question
Estar + Subject + Adjective?
Você está feliz?
Short Answer
Sim/Não + Estar
Sim, estou.
Continuous
Estar + Verb-ndo
Estou lendo.
Location
Estar + Em + Place
Estou em casa.

Formality Spectrum

Formal
Estou no escritório.

Estou no escritório. (Work)

Neutral
Estou no escritório.

Estou no escritório. (Work)

Informal
Tô no escritório.

Tô no escritório. (Work)

Slang
Tô no trampo.

Tô no trampo. (Work)

When to use Estar

ESTAR

Mood

  • feliz happy

Location

  • em casa at home

Health

  • doente sick

Examples by Level

1

Eu estou em casa.

I am at home.

2

Você está feliz?

Are you happy?

3

Nós estamos cansados.

We are tired.

4

Eles estão no trabalho.

They are at work.

1

Estou estudando português.

I am studying Portuguese.

2

A comida está fria.

The food is cold.

3

Estamos esperando o ônibus.

We are waiting for the bus.

4

Onde vocês estão?

Where are you all?

1

Estou muito ocupado com o projeto.

I am very busy with the project.

2

Ela está sempre distraída.

She is always distracted.

3

Estamos prontos para sair.

We are ready to leave.

4

O café está fechado hoje.

The cafe is closed today.

1

Estou sendo paciente com ele.

I am being patient with him.

2

O documento está assinado.

The document is signed.

3

Estamos todos de acordo.

We are all in agreement.

4

O clima está mudando.

The weather is changing.

1

Estou a par da situação.

I am aware of the situation.

2

O projeto está em fase de conclusão.

The project is in the completion phase.

3

Estamos diante de um dilema.

We are facing a dilemma.

4

A economia está em declínio.

The economy is in decline.

1

Estou por ver tal fenômeno.

I have yet to see such a phenomenon.

2

A questão está em aberto.

The question is open.

3

Estamos a ver navios.

We are left with nothing.

4

O assunto está em pauta.

The subject is on the agenda.

Easily Confused

The Verb ESTAR: Temporary 'To Be' (estou, está) vs Ser vs Estar

Both mean 'to be'.

The Verb ESTAR: Temporary 'To Be' (estou, está) vs Estar vs Ficar

Both can mean 'to be' in terms of location.

The Verb ESTAR: Temporary 'To Be' (estou, está) vs Estar vs Ter

Used for states like hunger/thirst.

Common Mistakes

Eu estou brasileiro.

Eu sou brasileiro.

Nationality is permanent.

A festa está na minha casa.

A festa é na minha casa.

Events use 'ser'.

Eu estou médico.

Eu sou médico.

Profession is permanent.

Ela está alta.

Ela é alta.

Height is a permanent trait.

Estou comendo o livro.

Estou lendo o livro.

Wrong verb choice.

Nós estamos amigos.

Nós somos amigos.

Friendship is a permanent state.

Onde está você?

Onde você está?

Word order is usually SVO.

Ele está sendo um bom homem.

Ele é um bom homem.

Character is permanent.

A aula está chata.

A aula é chata.

The nature of the class is permanent.

O filme está bom.

O filme é bom.

Quality is intrinsic.

Estou a ser feliz.

Estou feliz.

Redundant usage.

A situação está ser difícil.

A situação é difícil.

The nature of the situation.

Estou a pensar que...

Penso que...

Avoid continuous for mental states.

Sentence Patterns

Eu estou ___.

Eu estou em ___.

Eu estou ___ (verb).

Você está ___?

Real World Usage

Texting constant

Tô chegando!

Hotel Check-in very common

Estou no quarto 10.

Job Interview common

Estou muito interessado na vaga.

Ordering Food common

A sopa está muito salgada.

Social Media very common

Estou amando este lugar!

Travel common

Onde está o aeroporto?

💡

The 'Tô' Trick

In Brazil, use 'tô' for 'estou' to sound more natural.
⚠️

Don't mix Ser/Estar

Always ask: is this permanent or temporary?
🎯

Use with -ndo

Estar + -ndo is the easiest way to express current actions.
💬

Regional Variation

In Portugal, remember the 'a' + infinitive structure.

Smart Tips

Always use 'estar' for feelings.

Eu sou feliz hoje. Eu estou feliz hoje.

Use 'estar' for where you are.

Eu sou em casa. Eu estou em casa.

Use 'estar' + -ndo.

Eu como agora. Eu estou comendo agora.

Only use 'tô' with friends.

Estou em uma reunião (formal). Tô em uma reunião (informal).

Pronunciation

/to/

In informal speech, 'estou' becomes 'tô'.

Question

Você está bem? ↑

Rising intonation at the end.

Memorize It

Mnemonic

Estar is for the 'E' in 'E-temporary'.

Visual Association

Imagine a chameleon changing colors. The chameleon is 'estar' because its state is always changing.

Rhyme

If it's here today but gone tomorrow, use 'estar' to avoid the sorrow.

Story

Maria is at the beach (location). She is happy (mood). She is eating ice cream (action). All these things can change, so she uses 'estar'.

Word Web

estouestáestamosestãoaquiagora

Challenge

Write 3 sentences about where you are and how you feel right now using 'estar'.

Cultural Notes

Brazilians almost always use 'tô' instead of 'estou' in daily life.

In Portugal, 'estar' is used with 'a' + infinitive for continuous actions.

Usage is similar to Brazil, often very informal.

From Latin 'stare' (to stand).

Conversation Starters

Como você está hoje?

Onde você está agora?

Você está estudando muito?

Como está o tempo aí?

Journal Prompts

Describe your current room.
How are you feeling today and why?
What are you doing this weekend?
Describe a place you are visiting.

Common Mistakes

Incorrect

Correct


Incorrect

Correct


Incorrect

Correct


Incorrect

Correct

Test Yourself

Fill in the blank.

Eu ___ feliz.

✓ Correct! ✗ Not quite. Correct answer: estou
Mood is temporary.
Choose the correct form. Multiple Choice

Nós ___ em casa.

✓ Correct! ✗ Not quite. Correct answer: estamos
Nós matches estamos.
Correct the sentence. Error Correction

Find and fix the mistake:

Eu estou brasileiro.

✓ Correct! ✗ Not quite. Correct answer: Eu sou brasileiro.
Nationality is permanent.
Reorder the words. Sentence Reorder

Arrange the words in the correct order:

All words placed

Click words above to build the sentence

✓ Correct! ✗ Not quite. Correct answer: Eu estou em casa.
Standard SVO order.
Translate to Portuguese. Translation

I am eating.

Answer starts with: Est...

✓ Correct! ✗ Not quite. Correct answer: Estou comendo.
Estar + -ndo.
Match the subject to the verb. Match Pairs

Match each item on the left with its pair on the right:

✓ Correct! ✗ Not quite. Correct answer: estão
Eles matches estão.
Conjugate for 'Você'. Conjugation Drill

Estar

✓ Correct! ✗ Not quite. Correct answer: está
Você matches está.
Build a sentence. Sentence Building

Use 'estou' and 'cansado'.

✓ Correct! ✗ Not quite. Correct answer: Eu estou cansado.
Standard SVO.

Score: /8

Practice Exercises

8 exercises
Fill in the blank.

Eu ___ feliz.

✓ Correct! ✗ Not quite. Correct answer: estou
Mood is temporary.
Choose the correct form. Multiple Choice

Nós ___ em casa.

✓ Correct! ✗ Not quite. Correct answer: estamos
Nós matches estamos.
Correct the sentence. Error Correction

Find and fix the mistake:

Eu estou brasileiro.

✓ Correct! ✗ Not quite. Correct answer: Eu sou brasileiro.
Nationality is permanent.
Reorder the words. Sentence Reorder

estou / casa / em / Eu

✓ Correct! ✗ Not quite. Correct answer: Eu estou em casa.
Standard SVO order.
Translate to Portuguese. Translation

I am eating.

✓ Correct! ✗ Not quite. Correct answer: Estou comendo.
Estar + -ndo.
Match the subject to the verb. Match Pairs

Eles

✓ Correct! ✗ Not quite. Correct answer: estão
Eles matches estão.
Conjugate for 'Você'. Conjugation Drill

Estar

✓ Correct! ✗ Not quite. Correct answer: está
Você matches está.
Build a sentence. Sentence Building

Use 'estou' and 'cansado'.

✓ Correct! ✗ Not quite. Correct answer: Eu estou cansado.
Standard SVO.

Score: /8

Practice Bank

10 exercises
Fill in the blank Fill in the Blank

Onde vocês ___?

✓ Correct! ✗ Not quite. Correct answer: estão
Find the mistake Error Correction

Ela ser muito triste hoje.

✓ Correct! ✗ Not quite. Correct answer: Ela está muito triste hoje.
Put the words in order Sentence Reorder

estamos / Nós / shopping / no

✓ Correct! ✗ Not quite. Correct answer: Nós estamos no shopping
Translate 'I am ready' Translation

How do you say 'I am ready'?

✓ Correct! ✗ Not quite. Correct answer: Eu estou pronto
Select the formal version for 'How are you?' Multiple Choice

Asking a professor:

✓ Correct! ✗ Not quite. Correct answer: Como o senhor está?
Match the subject with the verb Match Pairs

Match them:

✓ Correct! ✗ Not quite. Correct answer: Eu - estou
Fill in the blank Fill in the Blank

A porta ___ aberta.

✓ Correct! ✗ Not quite. Correct answer: está
Correct the WhatsApp slang to formal Error Correction

Tô no Uber.

✓ Correct! ✗ Not quite. Correct answer: Eu estou no Uber.
Which verb is for temporary location? Multiple Choice

Choose one:

✓ Correct! ✗ Not quite. Correct answer: Estar
Translate 'They are tired' Translation

How do you say 'They are tired'?

✓ Correct! ✗ Not quite. Correct answer: Eles estão cansados

Score: /10

FAQ (8)

It comes from 'stare', meaning to stand. Standing is a temporary position.

No, name is permanent, use 'ser'.

No, it is very informal.

Just use a question mark or rising intonation.

Weather is temporary, so use 'está'.

It is almost identical.

No, job is permanent, use 'ser'.

It is 'estão'.

Scaffolded Practice

1

1

2

2

3

3

4

4

Mastery Progress

Needs Practice

Improving

Strong

Mastered

In Other Languages

Spanish high

estar

Very few differences.

French low

être

French lacks the permanent/temporary distinction.

German low

sein

No distinction between permanent and temporary.

Japanese partial

iru/aru

Based on animation, not permanence.

Arabic low

nominal sentence

No overt verb required.

Chinese moderate

shì / zài

Chinese 'zài' is specifically for location, not mood.

Learning Path

Prerequisites

Was this helpful?

Comments (0)

Login to Comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!